Helping fishermen reduce their impact

Full Solution
Panorama of Isla Isabel
CONANP

High levels of marine productivity around the National Park Isla Isabel attract fishermen, who have been using the island as a temporary camp site for almost 100 years. However, a steadily growing number of fishermen and a lack of organisation have increased the pressure on the island’s natural resources. CONANP initiated a participatory process with the local fishermen to improve the management of the fishing camp and ensure that all activities meet environmental regulations.

Last update: 30 Sep 2020
4728 Views
Context
Challenges addressed
Loss of Biodiversity
Unsustainable harvesting incl. Overfishing
Changes in socio-cultural context
Lack of public and decision maker’s awareness
Poor monitoring and enforcement
Poor governance and participation
  • Unregulated use of the island by fishermen impacting biodiversity
  • Conflicts between the island’s fishermen and national park operators
  • Missing involvement of fishermen in the management of the island
  • Governance of the island
Beneficiaries

The general public, national park operators and fishermen as well as tourism operators, park visitors and researchers.

Scale of implementation
Local
Subnational
Ecosystems
Coral reef
Theme
Protected and conserved areas governance
Local actors
Protected and conserved areas management planning
Marine litter
Location
Parque Nacional Isla Isabel, México
North America
Process
Summary of the process
tba
Building Blocks
Consensus on natural resource use

Regular meetings with relevant stakeholders, including representatives from academia, governmental agencies, national park staff and local fishermen, promote consensus regarding directives for the use and protection of natural resources.

Enabling factors

tba

Lesson learned

tba

Management plan for the National Park

The conservation and management programme formalizes jointly agreed regulations. It contains various sub-programmes with defined objectives, actions and guidelines to improve the state of conservation and management.

Enabling factors

tba

Lesson learned

tba

Education campaigns

Environmental education campaigns raise awareness of issues associated with the fishing camp. Special emphasis is placed on the control of introduced species, waste management and outdoor defecation. Information is disseminated via various media.

Enabling factors

tba

Lesson learned

tba

Roles and responsibilities within National Parks

Roles and responsibilities are defined for all stakeholders. To achieve the required compliance with administrative rules, stakeholders are actively involved in inspection and surveillance activities. The violation of an agreement can result in temporary denial of access to the island.

Enabling factors

tba

Lesson learned

tba

Thematic workshops for fishermen

Workshops are conducted to increase local fishermen‘s capacities. These focus on conservation, sustainable fishing techniques, biosafety measures and solid waste management. Meetings with fishermen from other protected areas in the region, NGOs and research centres facilitate knowledge transfer.

Enabling factors

tba

Lesson learned

tba

Impacts

The regulation of camping condensed in the recovery of previously irritated vegetation zones e.g. by ceasing to use trees as firewood to prepare food. The exploitation of native birds and reptiles of the island and their products stopped. The placement of the camping side with 30 ecological latrines ended open air defecation. Residuals have been eliminated and the risk of human introduction of alien species has been reduced. Fishermen do now participate in the conservation of the island; these actions also have been extended to the surrounding marine area. The conflicts between the fishermen and with the national park’s personal are decreasing. Moreover, if conflicts are emerging now there exist adequate canals and norms to solve them. For the operators of the national park the regulation of the camping resulted in an improved and more efficient use of their own resources. For the fishermen the security to have temporary camping during fishing activities, in this case far away from the coast, means lower investment costs and an increase in their economic activities.

Story

»With the new management approach, things have become better regulated,« says Juan Dovora, fisherman in Isla Isabel. »There is no longer such an uncontrolled arrival of fishermen. This was achieved by the hard work of the staff of the park, of Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México (UNAM), and of the government, who were engaged in fostering our compliance to the new rules, which turned out to be really beneficial. When the management plan was being discussed, we did not want to miss that opportunity. Now we try to give something back – to the extent that we supported them, we also support ourselves. Today the park is already being revived with all the jobs that are being created.«

Connect with contributors
Other contributors