Community beach patrols
The beach patrols occur at night to collect data and make sure the female turtles are not disturbed and slaughtered. The patrols are undertaken by 2 to 4 community persons groups which are led by a more experienced person of the Caretta Association. We collect data such as animal length, width, presence of external parasites, injuries, and localization of the nest. The data is collected and entered in a form to produce a further report and publication. Our constant presence on the beach is also a message to move away the poachers.
Proximity of the community to the beach. Aroused curiosity to see a sea turtle laying eggs.
This hands-on activity provided the community a different perspective and developed a sense of belonging. Before that they should all go through a training in order to make sure the presence of not experienced people does not become a threat.
Community beach clean-ups
We regularly organize beach cleaning-up campaigns at weekends, especially during vacation periods with students, to collect plastic bags and garbage. We communicate with the community through the local community radio and public events.
Creating a partnership with the environmental department of the city hall to take waste to its final destination.
The involvement of the community in solving their own problems is very inspiring and positively contagious. It improves the impact. However, I would advice a very efficient communication in order to not leave anyone out. All members of the community should feel useful in the process.
Integration of fisherfolk
Fisherman are addressed in their work place in informal conversations aiming to raise awareness on the impacts of their behavior. They are also regularly invited to participate in training sessions in which scientific data is shared. This expresses the need of changes in their behavior. We share scientific data such as conservation status of loggerhead turtles as an endangered species due to plastic ingestion, ocean pollution and other human actions (UICN). We also share information such as the prediction by the Ellen MacArthur Foundation and the World Economic Forum that “there will be more plastic than fish in the sea by 2050” if we do not change our behavior.
Fishermen are simple and humble people and can be easily accessed as they are members of the same community as the solution providers. After gaining their trust they become good solution partners.
Local fishermen are very knowledgeable people and their experiences are very useful and should be taken into account. Their daily activities provide them useful information that has been used to improve the solution. They know where the threats are stronger and where sea turtles are more vulnerable to hunting. Their knowledge has also assisted us in determining the best time of the day the sea turtles lay eggs, the main spots and the period of hatchings.
Success through involvement of local communities
The community is divided into 2 groups, children and adults. The children regularly participate in beach cleaning campaigns on weekends and help taking sea turtles hatchlings to the sea. Adults participate in harder work such as beach night patrols and collecting plastic from the sea.
Some members of the community are part of the solution. It facilitates carrying messages to the community and solves problems. By having a person from the community on our side inspires more confidence and brings more people together.
Any environmental project cannot succeed without the involvement of the local community. They are the people who better know their community. By engaging them you make sure the project continues in the future and is passed to the next generations. They should be involved in decision making, planning and the implementation of actions.
Transparent sharing of information
The results of the project have been shared with Belize’s Ministry of Forest, Fisheries and Sustainable Development (including Coastal Zone Management Authority and Institute and National Climate Change Office) and the Ministry of Tourism to facilitate replication, and uptake of the process and recommendations. The results have also been shared with local communities, local NGOs, land developers and the private tourism sector to build capacity, awareness and implementation of greener landscape practices within the coastal zone.
• Continuous and transparent sharing of information and best practices with communities and stakeholders. • Interest and wish to conserve the natural ecosystems exhibited by local communities, stakeholders and government decision-makers.
Working in partnership and building a sustained relationship with local communities and stakeholders (e.g. private tourism sector groups) on the Peninsula opened doors for us to influence better practices on the ground. This is very important since these groups can play important roles as advocates, sponsors, partners and agents of change. WWF has been carrying out conservation and climate adaptation related projects on the Placencia Peninsula since 2007, and over the years have built credibility within and among the communities and sectors on the Peninsula. Where there is trust, communication can be very effective.
Formative Research
During the planning phase extensive formative research informs the Social Marketing, as well as the Technical Assistance components of a campaign. Research sets the baselines that allow the assessment of social and conservation impacts following a campaign. Qualitative research (e.g. focus groups, observation, in-depth interviews) is geared towards understanding target audience opinions, feelings, concerns and perceived benefits of current as well as desired management practices. Qualitative research is about creating a casual conversation with and between participants to establish a comfortable relationship, and to reveal underlying information unobtainable through quantitative research. Quantitative research surveys capture specific answers to specific questions to describe demography, identify media preferences, and assess the current state of knowledge, attitude, communication and readiness of target audiences regarding a certain behavior change. Both components ultimately inform campaign decisions like objectives, respective activities, materials, and messages for both Social Marketing and Technical Assistance.
• Training on qualitative and quantitative research methods. • Generic qualitative research guide/procedure to support researcher in preparing and during research rounds. • Templates to facilitate qualitative research analyses. • Quantitative research (i.e. survey), following best practices for survey question design to avoid bias in respondent answers. • Committed base of volunteers to support survey implementation. • Software to process and analyze quantitative data.
Qualitative research techniques (e.g., focus group and in-depth interviews) geared towards understanding the target audience opinions, feelings and concerns regarding a certain behavior change are essential to create casual conversations for participants. This enables creating an environment of trust in which fishers feel comfortable expressing what they really think instead of expressing what others want to hear. The latter would make data barely reliable. Surveys that are built on qualitative research results tend to better inform campaign strategies, making them more aligned with campaign goals and objectives. It is essential to avoid setbacks when it comes to survey implementation, and detailed planning based on sample sizes and human resources is necessary. In that sense, building strong relationships with a committed group of campaign volunteers to support this task is essential.
Participatory land planning
To identify the intervention priority areas for the recovery of rice fields and mangrove restoration, it was necessary to rely on the populations’ intimate knowledge of their environment and the history of its evolution in relation to climate change. The main working tool was kite-photographing, which provided an overview of the land components, as the basis for defining land development priorities. It is a cost-effective technique which can be easily implemented locally, allowing a high level of stakeholder participation.
An easy-to-implement and cost-effective technology; Printed and enlarged photos, to facilitate the dialogue; Raise awareness about the impacts of climate change.
The persons handling the tool must be accompanied by facilitators who have a good knowledge of facilitation techniques and the issues related to land management options. Most of the time, the inhabitants themselves contribute the elements of landscape interpretation and its evolution, but they are often aware of the upcoming changes.
Mangrove restoration and monitoring
Restoration measures – including the reforestation of degraded mangrove areas with native species, the restoration of hydrological conditions and the removal of invasive exotic species – are implemented and the effects of these efforts continuously monitored.
tba
tba
Technical Assistance (TA)
Unlike Social Marketing, the Technical Assistance (TA) is based on more personal interactions with the fishers at the fishing group level (cooperatives or associations) or at the individual fisher level. This allows the issues to be addressed with more detail and depth, although larger groups of people are not reached. The overarching goal is to promote fishers´ support for conservation actions (e.g., creation of FRZ, adoption of sustainable fishing practices). Technical assistance tools are targeted towards building capacity in coastal communities and removing technical barriers, emphasizing leadership among fishers to improve the management of fisheries resources. Examples of technical assistance activities include one-on-one conversations, fishing trips, fisher exchanges among sites, formal training in specific fishing methods through workshops and courses, informal training, meetings with the authorities, follow-up with administrative and legal processes (e.g., fishing concession/permit renewal) and providing organizational materials (e.g., file cabinets, blackboards, etc.).
• High level of technical experience and skills of implementing partner allow deeper and more detailed TA interventions with fishers. • Well designed, implemented and analyzed formative research supports the definition of thematic areas for TA. • Partnerships with government agencies and NGOs to add human and financial resources and give fishers assurance that their effort is acknowledged. • Target audience participation in the design and future implementation of TA activities to generate ownership and contribute to reducing the resistance to the campaign effort.
Technical Assistance interventions help the campaign address issues identified in the Barrier Removal step, but interventions are not necessarily limited to that stage in the process. Despite the differences in the context of each campaign site, defined by the conditions of the country and the fishing industry, very similar thematic areas were identified for each TA strategy. Building trust with the fishers is a primary step for all TA activities. Those activities which involve as many fishers as possible generate ownership in fishers and facilitate the adoption of behaviors. Moreover, fishers are empowered to follow up on the agreements derived from each activity, improve their self-organization, establish agreements internally or with third parties to publicly reaffirm and guarantee their collective decisions, and promote their participation in activities that impact the fisheries management decision-making process.
Participatory CCA monitoring
The pressures of hunting and logging are gradually mounting in most of the forest areas resulting in forest degradation and decline in wildlife. In this backdrop, community conserved areas become attractive targets for certain segments of the village community and people from neighboring villages involved in illegal hunting of wildlife and exploitation of natural resources. There are also poaching reports of musk deer for glands (or musk pods) and the Himalayan black bear for gall bladder, paws and skins. Though management committees of the respective community conserved area frame the rules and regulations preventing hunting, illegal logging and over extraction of medicinal plants or associate non-timber forest products, continuous monitoring is needed to ensure that these are implemented. Keeping this issue in mind, the management committee identifies at least ten youths who are responsible to patrol their conserved area following human/ animal trails, monitor illegal movement of any suspect, dismantle traps and collect periodic data on biodiversity. This component helps monitoring forest and wildlife as well as record biodiversity information on the conserved area supporting future management planning.
- Identification of villagers who are competent for tracking and well informed on the forests. The herders/hunters are resourceful and well fit for the job - Financial supports for camping gear, equipment and operational costs - Ensuring the forest authority is informed for legitimacy of the actions, legal support for wildlife confiscation/ registering case in case of convictions - Ensure community supports this.
Even though the community undertakes patrolling and monitoring on their own, this effort needs regular capacity building inputs. Support from forest authority, legal awareness through regular capacity building programme on various parameters i.e. provisions under law for wildlife confiscation, registering a case for any instance of conviction and judicial support need to be ensured for optimal results. Before implementation of this component, it is important to make sure that the community understands legal issues; that they are supported by the forest authority, and receive basic training on how to handle equipment, collect and compile data for biodiversity monitoring.