Since its creation, MIHARI has always involved the government authorities, at the highest level. It has made the Ministries of Agriculture, Livestock and Fisheries, as well as of Environment, visible, as they were both cited as main partners, host of conferences, etc. MIHARI has also consulted the authorities along processes, such as the formalisation of a reference guide on LMMAs, the first of this kind in the country, to be hopefully eventually integrated in the national law.
Government officials are invited in all major fora and site visits, as sponsors.
Liaise and maintain good relationships with government officials, including Ministers.
Collaboration in the organization of key events, such as the workshop to enhance mud crab fisheries management.
It is very important to meet with government officials on a regular basis, so as to update them on ongoing and planned activities.
The SIMCA Enforcement steering committee meeting that discussed illegal fishing within and outside SIMCA
Reef Guardian/ Achier Chung
The success of enforcement work relies on collaboration from the authorities. The SIMCA Enforcement Steering Committee has been established to reduce illegal fishing activities within the marine protected area. The steering committee included Reef Guardian, Sabah Wildlife Department, Department of Fishery, Marine Police, Malaysia Navy, District Offices, Malaysia Maritime Enforcement Agency and Eastern Sabah Security Command. The Joint collaborative enforcement activities were conducted regularly to ensure efficiency in handling threats in illegal fishing, wildlife poaching and trafficking, illegal immigrant, and piracy issue within and outside of the marine protected area.
Close relationship with stakeholders
Persistency of partners to take action
Clear marine threats information for the authorities to plan for their actions
Effective enforcement needs collaboration from stakeholders from information gathering, consistence patrolling, effective detection and detention for court prosecution and crime conviction.
Enhance awareness and engagement with the local fishing communities
Engagement between Reef Guardian and Kampung Keniogan
Reef Guardian/ Achier Chung
The engagement between Reef Guardian and Kampung Terusan Sugut
Reef Guardian
The environmental awareness programme conducted with local communities from Kampung Terusan Sugut
Reef Guardian
The illegal fishing practice, such as illegal fish trawling at the shallow area local communities fishing grounds, impacts the sustainability of marine resources and the livelihood of local fishing communities. Implementing awareness programmes to the fishing communities and engaging them to be eyes and ears in reporting on the potential illegal fishing or activities in the sea.
The concern of fishing communities in the reduction of their catches from the illegal fish trawling in their common fishing grounds
Illegal fishing impact the fishing communities livelihood.
The engagement with fishing communities widens the enforcement capacity in a more extensive area.
The collaboration between Reef Guardian (Private sector) and fishing communities (stakeholders) safeguard marine habitats and reduce threats for the long-term sustainability of resources.
In the radar control room, Reef Guardian staff monitor potential boat intrusion to SIMCA.
Reef Guardian
Blast detector in the reef to record number of fishing blast over period of time
Reef Guardian/ Achier Chung
Investment in a radar tracking system for broader monitoring of the area. The radar tracking system is real-time monitoring speed, and directional heading of the boat in the marine protected area's vicinity. The radar information can infer the type of activity of the boat is likely to be engaged in the sea. For example, a fish trawler boat that is trawling tends to move at a slower speed of 7-10 kph than a passing trawler that usually travels at a speed of 16 – 20 kph. Furthermore, five blast detectors were installed to monitor and analyse blast fishing activities within SIMCA. The blast detector's information enables the Reef Guardian enforcement team to do strategic sea patrol to increase enforcement presence in the hot spot where illegal fish bombing often occurred.
Investment from a partner organization (Conservation International Philippine) on a radar tracking system in 2009.
Joint partnership with Reef Defender from Hong Kong since 2014 in the mission to reduce fish bombing in the region.
Information from the radar reduces operational cost (boat fuel) where the team show enforcement presence on the hot spot areas, instead of patrolling the entire marine protected area.
Radar information is best for night enforcement activities. The information giving a higher chance to intercept illegal fishing activities on the spot which lead to higher success on detection and detention rates.
Effective enforcement relied on the main four steps from Step 1 on detection of illegal fishing, Step 2 on successful detention of the suspect, Step 3 on the case prosecution and Step 4 on the criminal conviction. The Reef Guardian enforcement team plays an essential role in the early process of detecting illegal fishing. Enforcement guideline has been used to standardize the sea patrol operation, ensure the team safety and efficiency from boat check, and preserve all criminal evidence (protected species, illegal fishing equipment/substances). The guideline has been used as capacity training for systematic enforcement procedures to the recruit.
Experiences sharing from partners and team members to develop a straightforward strategy and guideline.
Sabah Environmental Court workshop emphasized the important preservation of the evidence for successful court prosecution and conviction.
Clear enforcement strategy procedures are essential for effective sea patrol.
Many cases fail in prosecution because of failure in evidence preservation for court prosecution.
Delegate each enforcement crew's task in each sea patrol operation to ensure the effective detention of illegal fishing vessels.
Enhance awareness and engagement with the local fishing communities
Joint collaborative enforcement
Participatory conservation of pilgrimage paths
Depending on their location, pilgrimage routes are owned by individuals, local or national governments who take care of their maintenance. Local inhabitants and Non-Profit Organizations (NPO) participate as well of the restoration, conservation and maintenance of some of the pilgrimage routes. For example, many preservation societies are active on the Iseji pilgrimage route where they conduct daily cleaning activities on the mountain passes where old roads remain. They also collaborate with patrolling after typhoons and heavy rains. These activities are recorded in the report and submitted to the respective Prefectural Board of Education via the respective Municipal Board of Education.
Japanese culture emphasizes on the caring for the public space and the benefit of the community as a whole, as well as supports a strong identification with and caring for the environment.
Support from the government and other agencies to facilitate citizen participation in volunteering activities, such as collection and distribution of donations.
The government will cooperate with citizens who initiate volunteer activities.
In the World Heritage property, some of the activities need a permission. This is something that needs to be confirmed in advance by the volunteers and the government.
Continuation of the traditional community-based conservation of secondary forests
Most of the forested areas of the Kii mountains have been planted because this area has traditionally been a place for logging. Trees are cut down every 50 to 100 years, and after the logging, people plant small trees. This traditional logging strategy has been done since the 16th century under a traditional technique such as seed collection, planting, planting density, thinning and felling especially in the Yoshino County, Nara Prefecture, where cherries are characteristic. Nara Prefecture has also introduced a tax for the conservation of the forest environment and is working with volunteers and private organizations through its municipalities to cut down abandoned forests. The abandoned forests have been replanted with broad-leaved trees instead of coniferous trees such as cedar and cypress, which are suitable for forestry, and mixed forests of coniferous and broad-leaved trees are being converted to forests that are free of human intervention in the future. In parallel with traditional tree-planting and harvesting, we are trying to maintain the forests and forest landscape in the Kii Mountains in a sustainable manner.
Traditional logging performed in the area for centuries and continuity of this tradition
Support from the government and other relevant authorities to continue with this tradition
In recent years, the number of forestry workers has been decreasing due to a reduction in the demand for timber, a rise in cost and a lack of successors. The number of abandoned forests has been increasing, which has been the main reason for the control of planting density. This has resulted in changes to the forest ecology, soil erosion due to poor undergrowth, favoring landslides, floods, droughts and other hazards provoking disasters.
The recent promotion of renewable energy has led to the construction of solar and wind power facilities. This has led to large-scale deforestation, and there are concerns that this may affect the preservation of the World Heritage site. It is necessary to establish a system for collecting information on the construction of these facilities and coordinating in advance, such as the preparation of guidelines, in order to ensure coexistence with the World Heritage.
Granting autonomy to religious bodies in the management of their sacred places (forests and temples)
Through the whole process that the sacred places in the Kii Mountains were being designated as cultural heritage and natural heritage (as part of a national park), and later included in the Biosphere Reserve, to finally be part of the World Heritage property, the religious bodies were officially granted their protection and management following the traditional knowledge carried for centuries, based on religious beliefs and sacred values. For instance, due to their sacred character, primeval forests have been conserved under strict felling prohibitions by the different religious communities.The mountain landscapes are interpreted as materialized “mandalas” by Shingon Buddhists, and Shugendo practitioners reproduce “mandalas” by doing pilgrimage and performing their ascetic practices in these natural environments. For pilgrims, the Kii Mountains represent the paradise on earth. Another example is the Nachi sacred forest that has been designated as a “Natural monument” under the Law for the Protection of Cultural Property, and the management has been done by the Kumano Nachi Shinto shrine, as part of their sacred place. The Nachi waterfall is regarded as sacred. This means that the sacred waters cannot be touched or diverted.
Persistent cultural practices, traditional and local knowledge based on the belief of sacredness of nature.
Legal protection under the Law for the Protection of Cultural Property and the Natural Parks Law are designed to relegate and uphold the traditional nature-human relationship without imposing frameworks that are inconsistent with religious-based protection.
Sacredness has protected the Kii Mountains primeval forests for more than 1,000 years and continuing. Enabling religious stewardship to continue practicing their traditions of forest conservation facilitates the conservation process.
Importance of the safeguarding of traditional knowledge and the spiritual values of local people to continuously protect the primeval forests.