Disseminate CBEMR knowledge through awareness initiatives by CBEMR Champions

Kuto/Cherono/Elizabeth, please add a description of this step 

Local Knowledge and Participation: CBEMR champions create awareness, assist in capacity building, undertake actual restoration activities, monitor restoration activities, and conduct ecological and social assessments, among other roles. 

Establishment of a CBEMR demonstration site for learning and research purposes in Lamu

Using data from the Global Mangrove Watch platform, we’ve been working with the KFS to identify 93.2 ha of potential restoration sites in Lamu. In partnership with the KFS we launched a demonstration site in the Kitangani area to address the underlying hydrological challenges which hinder natural mangrove regeneration and restore the environmental conditions such as soil, oxygen and nutrient quality, allowing for natural regeneration. 

Monitoring after six months showed clear improvement, with free-flowing water and visible signs of regrowth. This shows how successful correctly applied Ecological Mangrove Restoration approaches can be. This impactful restoration effort holds great promise for the revival of the degraded Kitangani mangrove ecosystem.

dsfdsds

Resource Gaps: Restoring mangroves requires significant investment in terms of time and financial resources, particularly in areas that have changed considerably. Stakeholders therefore need to take a long-term view of restoration initiatives and consolidate their resources and efforts. 

Awareness raising and capacity building on CBEMR amongst stakeholders in Lamu

Wetlands International commenced restoration efforts in Kitangani by bringing together a wide group of stakeholders. We engaged local communities through civil society organisations and the Lamu Community Forest Association (CFA), as well as Kenya Forest Service (KFS), the Kenya Forest Research Institute (KEFRI), the Kenya Marine and Fisheries Research Institute (KMFRI), and the Lamu County Government. 

[Kuto/Cherono/Elizabeth, please add more details on our engagement activities with these groups. E.g. did we collect socio-economic information from the site and wider landscape?  Did we discuss alternative livelihoods? Did we discuss the values of mangroves and benefits of restoration? Did we discuss why previous restoration attempts failed, etc?] 

These efforts resulted in a group of CBEMR champions that throughout the full process helped in creating further awareness, assisted in capacity building, in conducting ecological and social assessments, implementation and monitoring of restoration activities.   

Stakeholders were then trained on best mangrove restoration techniques, using the CBEMR approach. In collaboration with the Mangrove Action Project (MAP) and KFS, Wetlands International trained community organisations, government and county officials, forest managers, research institutions, academia from several universities, media and civil society from Lamu, Tana River, and Mombasa counties. From the communities, women had a 50 per cent representation, as it is them who are mainly involved in actual restoration efforts. 

Participatory and Holistic Approaches: The CBEMR approach is participatory and provides a holistic view of the landscape and the restoration process. It connects resource users with research institutions, the local government, national conservation and law enforcement agencies, and civil society and build on their local and expert knowledge. 

Gender Roles and Social Groupings: Women are key in mangrove restoration and conservation activities. Men, who are mostly breadwinners, spend most of their time fishing or pursuing other livelihood or economic activities and are therefore not keen on engaging in conservation initiatives. Gender roles and social groupings are therefore critical when planning mangrove conservation and restoration initiatives. 

Local Knowledge and Participation: CBEMR champions create awareness, assist in capacity building, undertake actual restoration activities, monitor restoration activities, and conduct ecological and social assessments, among other roles. 

Lamu has relatively well-established community-based organisations that have a growing interest in mangrove restoration. 

Capacity Building and Knowledge Sharing: There exist knowledge gaps in mangrove conservation and restoration within communities, conservation institutions, and research organisations. There is therefore need for continuous capacity building and knowledge sharing.

 

One Health Task Force (OHTF)

The One Health Task Force (OHTF) is a collaborative platform for the local government. It usually mirrors the structure of the One Health platform at the national level. The OHFT generally consists of 5-7 people representing the local administration and the core line ministries (Health, Agriculture and Livestock, Environment and Natural Resource or equivalent). Other members may include representatives from the Women and Social Affairs, Education, and Disaster Risk Prevention and Management. The OHTF oversees the organization and delivery of the integrated health services via the OHU and guarantees the monitoring of its performance. OHTF members are trained on the concept of One Health and the Standard Operating Procedures for the establishment of the OHU. Selected OHTF members are trained as trainers to support cascading the training to service providers and other government staff. By taking increasing ownership and responsibility, the OHTF ensures the sustainability of the OHU and its gradual recognition and funding as effective service delivery model for pastoralist communities. 

  • National One Health structure in place to ease operationalisation at the community level

The OHTF can facilitate the communication with One Health institutions at the sub-national and national level, promoting the recognition of the OHU in national development and strategic plans.

Multi-Stakeholders Innovation Platform (MSIP)

The Multi-Stakeholders Innovation Platform (MSIP) is a collaborative platform for community members. It includes about 15-20 women and men selected by the community and representing different community groups (e.g., traditional and religious leaders, community-based service providers, traditional healers, teachers, businessmen/women, representatives from the local rangeland institution). Where possible, MSIPs build on already established and functional groups that work at the community level on a voluntary basis. MSIP members are trained on the concept of One Health, leadership and management. Other training activities can be organised to enhance their skills and competencies and ensure their active engagement in specific community-based interventions. The MSIPs meet on monthly basis to discuss local issues and jointly identify suitable solutions to, for example, disease outbreaks and other health threats, livestock densities and movements, pasture availability, and water access.

  • Initial engagement of traditional and local leaders to increase community ownership  
  • Balanced representation of all groups to ensure participation of the entire local community

Non-financial incentives (e.g., training, clean-up kits, visibility items) motivate the voluntary-basis group and can support its active engagement in the long-run. 

One Health Unit (OHU)

The One Health Unit (OHU) is a collaborative platform for service providers and community-based actors. It serves as primary means for the planning and delivery of integrated human, animal, environmental and rangeland health services at the community level. The OHU can be mobile, static or a mix of the two delivery modes. Mobile OHUs follow the routes of pastoralists and their livestock, providing services according to a monthly schedule and addressing the needs of different herding communities. Static OHUs provide services from a shared facility (e.g., human/animal health post, water point or other village gathering site) where service providers work side by side. The OHU is staffed by service providers coming from different government departments, including health workers from the local Health Office or referral Health Facility, animal health technicians from the local Livestock Office or any public or private veterinary facility, and National Resource Management officers or Environmental Health officers from the local Office. The OHU also includes community-based actors (such as Community Health Volunteers and Community Animal Health Workers) which facilitate the mobilisation of people and guide the discussion around health threats and other events affecting local communities.

  • Joint training of service providers to create trust and support collaborative approaches
  • Joint supportive supervision to further the collaboration across sectors during service delivery

Gender-balanced OHU team can improve the quality and acceptability of health services and ultimately increase their utilisation by all community members.

Study on the Carrying Capacity

As part of the Management Plan for the Guadalupe Environmental Protection Area (APA) and in support of the ZATAN, the environmental agencies of Pernambuco (Semas/PE and CPRH) conducted a study on the carrying capacity of the beaches and reefs in Tamandaré and Sirinhaém, as well as on Santo Aleixo Island. The study provides calculations and recommendations regarding the number of visitors, vessels, and tourist activities that this region can support without compromising its natural characteristics and the health of its ecosystems.

Specifically, the study indicates that the number of vessels operating in the estuary of the Formoso River should be limited to 129 boats per day. Additionally, catamarans are restricted to a maximum of 60 passengers each, and small boats are limited to 9 passengers.

For further details regarding the maximum number of visitors and vessels allowed at specific embarkation and disembarkation points, please refer to the clipboards distributed in the region.

The study encompassed various areas, including areas for circulation of vessels, embarkation and disembarkation, visiting reefs, recreational use, nautical activities and boat trips. In order to implement such a complex study and obtain robust and detailed results to guide the management of the area, in-depth knowledge of the region, established relationships with local stakeholders and direct access to the areas are indispensable. Relying solely on theoretical knowledge and secondary data from desk studies is insufficient.

The study on the area’s carrying capacity was crucial to determine the specific number of boats, passengers and visitors that the area can support without compromising the health of its ecosystem, and to subsequently provide more concrete guidelines for implementing the zoning instrument (ZATAN). In addition, transforming the information of the study into user-friendly communication products, such as the clipboards, is essential to ensure that local stakeholders, especially local boat owners, tourism companies and authorities, are aware of these limits, and adhere to and enforce the regulation. 

Institutionalisation

With the zoning proposal agreed in the workshops, 116 representatives of the various segments of the community in the Formoso estuary region participated in a public hearing that was open to all stakeholders. As a result of the commitment and collaboration of all stakeholders, a decree was drafted and approved in January 2021, at the 100th meeting of the Council of the State of Pernambuco (Consema). Decree no. 50.049/2021 establishes rules for nautical activities in the estuary of the Formoso River, including for recreational, tourist and traditional fishing activities. It also regulates which activities are permitted, prohibited (e.g. visitation, fishing) or encouraged (e.g. monitoring, research, cleaning) in specific areas of the estuary. It proclaims the importance of protecting and preserving the ecosystem and the livelihoods of local communities.

The involvement of all members of the community was important to promote an understanding of the need for arrangements to ensure the continuity of activities for the livelihoods of the communities in the region, while respecting the environment and the specific characteristics of the area. The active involvement of local stakeholders in the process strengthened their role as guardians of the region. The continuous participation of the stakeholders and their commitment to addressing environmental and territorial issues facilitated the implementation of certain measures proposed by ZATAN even before the State Decree was published.

The public hearing was particularly important to facilitate exchange between the different sectors and authorities, and to facilitate the participation of citizens in the decision-making processes. This extensive and rich process of participation and contribution from everyone made it possible to agree upon and approve a state decree to institutionalise the zoning instrument (ZATAN).

Building the Participatory Proposal

The area is very complex and dynamic in terms of socioeconomic and environmental change and cannot be analysed on the basis of secondary data alone. It was therefore necessary to observe and listen to the people who live and work in the region. After a period of interviews, site visits, and various technical, institutional and local meetings, three participatory workshops were conducted.

In a participatory process, consulting all stakeholders about the various interests in the area and about the different points of view regarding the zoning of the area is essential. The effective participation of local and institutional actors enabled an environment conducive to exchanging information, recording knowledge and propositions, and subsequently institutionalising the zoning instrument with the support of local stakeholders.

The process involved intensive listening, negotiation and conflict mediation. Effective participation fostered an atmosphere of unity and collective exchange that was fundamental for the success of the workshops and the overall process.

Preliminary Diagnosis and raising awareness of stakeholders

The first meeting to plan the ZATAN process took place in July 2018. In the same month, several technical meetings were held with the institutions involved to agree on the activities required for setting up the zoning process. The preliminary diagnosis of the ZATAN consultant team began with extensive research and analysis of existing data and documents, such as environmental impact studies, dissertations and theses, environmental laws, spatial and environmental planning instruments, as well as management plans for the area.

Based on this analysis, several field visits were made to observe the particularities of the territory. In addition to the observation process, interviews were conducted with fishermen and -women, boat owners, shellfish gatherers, and traditional communities such as Quilombolas, among others. The aim was to understand the local reality, map nautical activities and raise awareness among the various stakeholders of the importance of their participation in developing the ZATAN. 

Not only did the team analyse the area, its environmental vulnerabilities and potential, they also listened to the people who live in the area. The goal was to understand the dynamics of local nautical and tourist activities and the related conflicts and, above all, to engage people in the process.

The engagement of the diverse stakeholders throughout the whole process of developing the zoning instrument was an important outcome of the awareness-raising initiatives carried out during this period.