Implementation and monitoring

Contractual agreements with German enterprises RISTIC GmbH and ALNATURA have been achieved in 2015 resp. 2016 (50.000,00 US$ each). FUNDECODES, the Conservation Credit Unit (CCU) selling organization ASEPALECO and Costa Ricas National Protected Area Authority (SINAC) are responsible for the implementation of the restoration and conservation project and contractually agreed to 10 year objectives. FUNDECODES is reporting annually to the CCU buying company RISTIC GmbH. The whole process is monitored annually by Globale Conservation Standards (GCS).

  • FUNDECODES has been supported by GIZ in developing a marketing strategy to sell CCU at national and international level
  • GIZ provided coaching by demand to implement marketing and MRV to GCS, Ristic GmbH  

After 3 years of taylor made technical and financial GIZ support to the whole process, nowadays FUNDECODES has achieved full owenership and responsibility to manage the process by itself.

Action: Mangrove restoration laboratories

The underlying strategy of this building block is - instead of pursuing quantitative goals of restored areas -, to start with small, concrete actions such as mangrove seed nurseries and field trials with the communities. This helps to reduce barriers and leads to tangible and immediate results. In combination with the development and dissemination of information materials and participatory monitoring, it helps to showcase mangrove restoration as a means of adaptation to climate change by local actors. In addition, it strengthens the capacities of local stakeholders and institutions and generates synergies (see building block II).

  • Close collaboration with local stakeholders and continuous guidance.

  • Empowerment of the communities to maintain the ecosystem and improve the provision of ecosystem services important for their livelihoods.

  • While results in terms of restored area are still limited, investments in capacity development and governance of the area are expected to result in medium and long-term social, ecological and economic impacts.
  • For mangrove restoration, the area should be zoned according to social and environmental criteria: 1) priority areas where reforestation should be initiated immediately; 2) areas where other types of interventions should be carried out prior to reforestation (such as dredging, sensitization and training of surrounding local populations, removal of sewage discharges); and 3) other areas where mangrove can be left to recover alone (MAE and GIZ 2016).
Community Engagement & Behavior Change

The behaviour change campaign team at each municipality uses a mix of creative materials and community mobilization activities to inspire and educate fishers and their families about the benefits of working together to manage their fisheries better.  In the ‘Readiness’ phase, the messages are focused on getting fishers to become registered fishers, complying with basic fishing laws, and participate in meetings. In the second phase, after the managed access areas are institutionalized, the messages focus on building compliance for the rules and monitoring of their catch.  Through social marketing, Fish Forever can more easily earn buy-in from communities to follow best practices for fishing and encourage new solution innovations from communities for sustainable fisheries management.

A strong sense of place and identity among fishers in communities and active support of municipal and village leaders, combined with motivated and efficient Fish Forever and Rare staff, has enabled sites in Brazil to replicated their success in other regions.

Many commonalities exist between sites, so campaigns were able to use and adapt materials from other municipalities also focusing on fisheries management. Local adaptation, especially of mobilization activities, helped to make the campaigns more site-specific and ‘ownable’ by the community.

Participatory land use planning

In order to properly monitor the participatory implementation of the programme a “Community Management Group” (CMG) has been established. Members of the group were selected via an open voting involving all municipality members. The CMG members represent all economic and social groups that depend on natural resources (e.g. cattle breeders, beekeepers, gardeners…) including women and youth. During the planning and implementation phase of the erosion control measures, the CMG meets regularly, informs on the current situation, discusses challenges and decides on further steps. The CMG presents its proposal and comments on the management of public land (communal land) to relevant stakeholders of the District Administration, the Property Committee, the Rayon Agriculture Department and the regional department of the Ministry of Ecology. After incorporating the feedback from different stakeholders the CMG approves the implementation of the programme activities. Moreover the CMG is a mechanism to negotiate diverging interests and solve occurring conflicts.  

  • Mapping of ecosystem services and understanding of its contribution to human well-being.
  • Existence of traditional knowledge and skills regarding the collective use of natural resources.
  • Existence of a relevant legal bases (environment) and willingness of corresponding authorities to participate in the planning process.

Plan and organize regular meetings

  • The benefit of the applied measures for land users should be clearly explained to the decision makers.
  • The involvement of all relevant stakeholders is mandatory to prevent exclusion and conflicts that would otherwise negatively impact the programme.
  • Moderators can facilitate the decision making process (e.g. conflict mitigation).
  • External experts will contribute to planning and implementation (technical, institutional advice).
  • Inviting relevant ministry representatives to community meetings may create conflicts if the community is not aware of corresponding laws and regulations. It is recommended to explain current laws and regulations to the community members beforehand.
  • Women, as main users of natural resources, are not always involved in decision making. Involving women will highly affect the sustainable use of natural resources.
  • Participatory land use planning should use traditional knowledge and skills of the target group to maintain long-term gains.
Erosion control measures

Implemented erosion control measures contribute to the conservation of biodiversity through the protection of natural resources from anthropogenic induced erosion processes and through the rehabilitation of degraded areas. Special attention is paid to the causes and underlying drivers of erosion in order to develop strategies to improve erosion control at local level. Together with national partners Ismayilli district of Azerbaijan was selected as a pilot region.

Different erosion control measures are conceptualized and implemented through the cooperation of national and local partners, involving relevant stakeholders, international and local experts and local villagers. In order to rehabilitate the eroded lands and avoid further land degradation locally applicable erosion control measures are introduced to the land users. Measures include ‘grey’ measures (terraces, fences) as well as ‘green’ measures (afforestation, orchard management) and are combined with alternative income generating practices.

Socio-economic and ecological benefits of better land management and erosion control measures are monitored, documented and demonstrated to surrounding communities.

  • Understanding and ownership of the problems by land users are an essential part of successful implementation of erosion control.
  • Strong exchange between land user and relevant scientist.
  • Capacity development for land users.
  • Demonstrate economic value of erosion control measures.
  • A strong understanding of the social structure of the community as well as the local environment is key for the development of an erosion control concept.
  • Measures should be locally applicable and tangible for the farmers.
  • Reliable results are necessary to convince farmers (shown on the pilot sites and monitoring plots of the project).
  • It is vital to test and demonstrate different erosion control measures to showcase what measures have the most impact on which erosion situations and foster understanding for the solutions.
  • Involvement of local communities in the construction of the measures (manpower and material).
  • Develop an upscaling concept, making local experiences sustainable, e.g. an erosion control handbook for the South Caucasus region.
Continuous Aftercare

The removal of some or all of the woody plants creates a vacuum that will invariably be re-populated by woody plants, sometimes by more aggressive species. Natural defences against this phenomenon include a healthy and strongly competitive grass layer, and large bushes that are able to suppress the re-establishment and survival of new bush seedlings.

 

Despite these natural allies in the fight against re-infestation of aggressive woody species, an aftercare programme is absolutely essential to keep a thinned area open. This can be done in several ways such as mechanical slashing of new seedlings, localised (selective) chemical treatments of new growth, or even applying less popular management options such as controlled burning in combination with browsers. An efficient grazing management system that will ensure the maintenance of a healthy grass layer is also essential.

 

The most important aspect of an aftercare programme is that it should not be viewed as a once-off operation, but should become a permanent component of the day-to-day management of the farm.

 

  • Knowledge of the importance of aftercare and appropriate methodologies
  • Documented best practices, showing the long-term affect of aftercare as compared to no aftercare
  • Financial means for aftercare activities
  • Aftercare is often not implemented, since the there is little awareness of the negative consequences that occur when no aftercare is implemented
  • Bush control and aftercare are a continuous process, not a once-off intervention
Monitoring and being vigilant and active in implementation

Though ensuring the registration of a surf break is no easy task, it is critical to ensure thata once a surf break is recognized and registered, actions are taken to ensure that the promises and advantages of protection are delivered to all actors, and local fishing communities in particular. This building bloc implies, for example: regular capacity building and interaction with children and youngsters; cleaning of beaches campaigns; recognition of local champions and leaders; monitoring development initiatives (e.g. in infraestructure which may affect a surf break), regular mettings with local actors to explore ways in which the local environment an be improved, etc.    

1. Good relations with local communities and all involved actors. 

2. Available resources to undertake montoring and vigilance activities and actions. 

3. Permanent travel and visits by Do it for Your Wave to each registered surk break. 

4. Good communications and networking activities.  

This particular building bloc is key in the step by step process suggested. Actual formal protection is almost a FIRST step in a more long term effort to ensure integrity of surf breaks and their surroundings. Resources need to undertake a close monitoring of what is happening oin each site, regularly. Things may change rapidly, including if agreements have been set to ensure for example, that no infraestructure affects these sites (negatively). This has proved to be  a key challenge as expectations by all actors are often high. Protecting the surf break should enable a tangible benefit to all. This needs to be documented carefully and disseminated to ensure all actors are aware about the positive change taking place. 

Participation of women and girls

Women in Vanuatu play a critical role in the use and management of marine and terrestrial biodiversity, deciding what resources are harvested and in what quantities for sale in markets. By empowering women through participation in conservation committees, the NPMLPA network has been able to effect change at the individual and household level.

The coral gardening project is especially relevant for island women and girls. Many of them learned how to guide visitors to snorkel and collect fragments of coral for the climate reef garden. Women are typically those who collect the living coral fragments that have broken off the reef and are perfect for planting. Each piece of coral is extremely delicate and must be handled with care. Monitoring indicates that coral fragments collected by women have a 75% survival rate while those handled by men have only a 55% success rate. Since the inception of the program, GIZ has worked to encourage women to take the role of resource champions in each of the Nguna-Pele committees, offering special gender-focused trainings and capacity development workshops. The obvious benefit to women is that they can earn previously unavailable income from guiding for and helping guests plant coral fragments.

  • Recognized role of women in the Nguna-Pele MLPA network
  • Special training and gender-sensitive coral mariculture capacity building exercises
  • Monitoring and Evaluation of the program that is age and gender disaggregated

The marine environment is not typically the domain of women and girls in Vanuatu. This program has, for the first time, given a very clear and specific role for women to directly engage with coral. For many it was the first time they had been empowered to don mask and fins to do “work” underwater.  The lesson was that women took a very different view of the reef than their male counterparts. Rather than a habitat for fish, as seen through a male fishermen’s eye, the reef became a “nursery” for growing living coral.

Commission for the management and protection of sea turtles.

1.By consensus of the interested parties, INCOPESCA, ADIO, UCR, and SINAC created a commission of co-management and created a legal framework established with executive decree DAJ-020-2005, in order to work together and this group of Co-management launches a management plan for the conservation and sustainable use of turtles (Lepidochelys olivacea) nesting on Ostional beach.

The SINAC and INCOPESCA authorization and supervision of the Ostional Development Association (ADIO) to use eggs as a means of subsistence (consumption and sale). The community benefits from consumption of the egg as food and also to receive the economic resources that are distributed between people and social welfare, while contributing to the conservation of the turtle, through the cleaning of the beach and the care Of turtle hatchlings.

 

Leaning from the results of the first phase (2006-2011) progress was made in fulfilling population recovery objectives. The analysis of research advances made in the last five years and the sessions valuation that each of the actors did on experiences informed the 2013 – 2016 5-year plan; so did negotiations and agreements between the parties.

Representatives of the ADIO, UCR, INCOPESCA and SINAC developed jointly and by consensus four products that were the basis for the development of the new five-year management proposal:

  • A basic characterization of the roles of the actors and the main elements of their experience, which identified the keys to a successful plan for future use.
  • An interpretation framework as reference to outline the guidelines of the use plan for the next five years;
  • the principles governing the plan
  • general and specific rules and objectives.
SOME website

GRID-Arendal has created a pilot, web-based system to capture, analyse and display state of the marine environment assessment results: http://some.grida.no. The website allows for the real-time capture and display of data (scores for parameters, confidence, risks) during the workshop and provides an online template for the production of a State of Marine Environment Report. The content and graphics can be exported and used as the basis for a national or regional SOME report or the contents can be adapted for use within other formats as required. The database allows direct correlation to the outline of the World Ocean Assessment, thereby permitting cross-referencing and combining outcomes of the assessment to optimize it as a contribution to the international effort. Another key aspect is that the diagrams and outputs that are produced by the web site are designed for easy communication of the workshop results to policy- and decision-makers. The diagrams are simple, jargon-free and clearly communicate the main findings of the judgments made by the experts.

The system is used at the expert elicitation workshop.

The web-tool