Monitoring Growth and Success of Planted Mangroves
o Mangroves flourish more in some environments over others. The changing marine environment makes monitoring of red mangroves surviving from past plantings extremely valuable. Monitoring provides insight on the most successful intertidal zones, water depths, soil depths, and planting techniques. Monitoring of surviving mangroves ensures the survival of future planted mangroves.
Founded in 2008, GMR is the only organized effort to restore the mangrove forests destroyed by Hurricane Mitch in 1998.
Through monitoring, we have learned the best times and sites to plant mangroves that will reduce mortality and enhance biodiversity.
Transparent co-management
The Management Team is composed of the Municipal Mayor as Honorary Chairman; the Management Board; park officers and members of 7 working committees. The municipal and the two village government units; each composed of multi-sector representatives, comprise the Management Board. Each group contributes a specified amount for the project’s operational expenses. The Management Board members hold quarterly meetings and a general assembly of all Management Team members is conducted annually.
The Management team created a working organization and operations structures to ensure that there is a good coordination within in terms of functions and responsibilities. A governing internal policy is also adopted to instill that discipline and obedience to the goals and vision of the creating the marine protected area. To continue their day-to-day operations, the Local Government Unit provided yearly funds to finance logistics and other operational related expenses needed by the team.
Since the members of the ManComm are officials of the barangay, they feel the management of the PMMP is part of their duties and responsibilities as officials of the barangay. Easy access for funds intended for the food allowance and appropriate supplies and equipment for the Coastal Law Enforcement Team. Decisions are made in right venues like regular meetings and assembly with right stakeholders involved . PMMP plan is easily adopted and integrated in the municipal development plan.
A clear rights framework for community ownership
After the democratization of the country in 1994, the Makuleke community was one of the first communities in South Africa to win a land claim in 1998. As part of the Settlement Agreement, the Makuleke community were given the rights to develop the area for the socio-economic benefit of the community, as long as the land was used for conservation. It was also agreed that the area would be managed through a co-management arrangement with KNP.
Support from the national government; relevant national frameworks
Please contact solution provider for more information
Fair enforcement
When a violator from one village is apprehended, the case is resolved by members from the other village, thereby reducing the possibility of patronage politics. Representatives from the local government, church, people’s organizations, and NGOs, are allowed to observe the proceedings but cannot influence the outcome resulting to more effective law enforcement. Hands-on leadership, team-building strategies (e.g. cross-visits), and technical support are key in order to harmonize the different and sometimes conflicting interests of the multi-stakeholder organizational set-up.
Functional PMMP Enforcement Team - Provision of coastal law enforcement paraphernalia, equipment and support infrastructure facilities. Conduct of capability building training to enhance enforcement skills of the law enforcers - Cooperation with the local community and Municipal Fishwarden in reporting intrusion s and other violations in the municipal park. In place enforcement system such as logbook, sea patrol operation scheme and enforcement feedback
Regular meeting of the enforcement committees enabled the ManCom to monitor issues, problems and concerns. The Local Municipal Government Unit and the MPA Management Body should provide all the needed infrastructure, equipment and supplies/materials to increase the enforcement capacity of the team. Putting the logbook system for MPA Enforcement greatly helped in monitoring the activities and happenings in the MPA and provided timely feedback and response mechanism to further strengthen MPA enforcement.
Property associatation, accountable to community
They set up a Communal Property Association (CPA) accountable to community members, which manages their land asset and the partnerships with SANParks and private tourism concessionaires.Good governance: The CPA has 15 years of trying to maximise the benefit to the community through tourism leases and conservation related activities. They are an example of good governance and accountability to the vision, community and partnership agreements.
Shared vision:: The Makuleke and their private sector partners as well as SANParks share the same mission for the land: “contribute to sustainable long term socio-economic benefit for the Makuleke community…”.
NGO and Donor support for the community is critical. The community is not able to negotiate and manage private sector concessionaires and their relation with SANParks without getting help from NGO’s or government. Over the last 17 years there have been many conflicts and difficult decisions that the CPA needed professional input on. They were lucky that they had lots of support from international donors and local NGOs.
Developing a management plan of shared solutions
The joint identification of priority areas for intervention and solutions, using already existing (local) ideas and set-ups, is key. Livelihood diversification and adaptation technique are developed in order to decrease the direct pressure on natural resources and decrease the dependency of communities to these local resources, threatened by climate change (e.g. developing various forms of aquaculture, marine product processing, improved fish trade marketing, supporting certification for sustainable fisheries, ecotourism, etc.).
High-quality preliminary work (1) to ensure a shared understanding of issues between various types of stakeholders and strong ownership (2) are providing the basis towards a successful management plan. Local commitment and involvement in the implementation phase is key, as well as willingness to replicate in new areas. Local NGOs are actively working to support local communities to diversify and expand livelihoods activities.
It is also vital to encourage local communities and local authorities to identify issues and come up with their own solutions which can be applied at the local level. The involvement of National government representatives is also a guarantee that the project will follow national guidelines and policies on protected areas management, climate change and wetlands management.
Baseline data collection
Scientific data collection with input from relevant stakeholders, through public consultations and government, includes biophysical status and condition of the area, socio-economic status, resource use and preferences, governance, organisational and policy structures. Document data in a public document (Nusa Penida Profile). The profile helps to determine criteria for establishment of protection zones and as input for discussions with local stakeholders.
High diversity of marine ecosystem and biota
The combination of scientific data and traditional knowledge provides best information and baseline information for MPA planning. However, MPA planning should not be delayed until a perfect data set is available.
Participatory Monitoring of Threats
The Monitoring and Evaluation Plan is a guide in tracking and measuring the status of the marine habitat and its organisms, the threats and likewise the management efforts poured out to the marine park. The Coastal Law Enforcement Team continues writing the logbook and reflect the guarding, patrolling, surveillance, every activity and event happening in the campaign site and periodically summarize or consolidate the logbook entries on a regular basis and submit reports to the Coastal Resource Management Office. The Local Monitoring Team does the regular biophysical assessment, fish catch monitoring, socio-economic and community perception survey. Annually, the ManComm will be assessed using the MEAT by an independent evaluator from outside the campaign site. We will improve the competencies and skills of the members of the ManComm through trainings, constant coaching and mentoring so that they will become efficient in doing these tasks. We will also capacitate some members of the MTWG in data analysis and results presentation so that evaluation results will be presented in such a way that the people in the community could easily understand
Local volunteers to compose the monitoring team including women fisher and wives of fishers in the community. Constant capacitation of the monitoring team through trainings of necessary monitoring tools, cross visits to successful MPA sites and provision of appropriate monitoring equipment. Biophysical assessment is regularly conducted in the PMMP by the Local Monitoring Team. They are also involved in analyzing and presenting the data. Monitoring Results are used by the PMMP ManCom and the LGU to inform management decisions
Fish catch monitoring report is a useful source of information to evaluate the threats and the conservation results. Women have a critical role to perform of Encourage more women (fishers’ wives) to submit monthly report. Give incentives to cooperative family of fishers. Allocation of funds for monitoring must be secured to conduct regularly the necessary monitoring activities in the site. Regular Monitoring and Evaluation (M&E) is an important aspect in managing the Municipal Marine Park since it allows us to keep track on how far we have achieved our conservation goals. Training of second liners to compose the monitoring team is very important to increase the membership and meet the activities related to monitoring Informing the community especially the fishers about the results of the monitoring will inspire them to take part of their roles towards the management of the MPA especially
Consultative development: zoning and management plan
Formalise and enhance local customs and institutions legally. Conduct consultations (in the case of Nusa > 30) with community groups, government, and private dive operators with specific attention directed to each stakeholder group’s context. Identify core zones of high resilience, thus high conservation value. Core zones have high coral reef biodiversity serving as spawning sites, and no coral bleaching during temporarily high sea-surface temperatures.
• Commitment from local government on MPA establishment • Community support and culture that respects nature and acknowledges peoples’ dependence on coastal and marine resources • Location of the MPA close to the mainland (access) and not too large in terms of size for management reasons
Planning and developing an MPA should involve a range of central and local government agencies, the local community(ies) concerned, marine tour operators and other marine users.
Establishment of plot rendering
Plot rendering is based on a strong partnership between a municipality, the association of farmers in the county (or pastoral Group) and the Pyrenees National Park. The town, which owns the land, extends and provides the plot. The Pastoral Group is responsible for the plot. It supplies the plot with dead carcasses naturally in its operations, and cleans it regularly. The Pyrenees National Park follows the population of vultures, initiated the project, and technically and financially supports the development of the plot.
The ongoing dialogue between all partners (community, pastoralists, government agencies and National Park) has clarified the need for health monitoring and identified constraints to take into account when planning the plot. The establishment of this plot, accepted by all partners and managed efficiently, took nine months of negotiations. French regulations strongly regulate the fate of animal carcasses. One key to the success of this project lies in the support of the state and taking into account the population of vultures in this area.
The local context of interactions between livestock and vultures was complicated, with several complaints about interventions of vultures with livestock. The 9 months of project development have highlighted the fact that it is essential to rely on an existing group. It would have been unrealistic to create the breeders’ association to manage the plot rendering. This is the first plot in France managed by a group of farmers. The plots are highly regulated (type and quantity of deposits, health monitoring ...), and collective responsibility can be cause for concern. In this case, although adjustments were necessary, the empowerment of actors has been a success. The last lesson of the project was the strong involvement of the community, the services of the State and National Park, otherwise the project would not have succeeded.