Modeling the ecosystem with little data

By their nature, small-scale fisheries tend to have limited, poorly systematized data and short time scales. This scarcity of information represents a challenge for understanding, for example, the interaction of fishing gear with the ecosystem and its impact on the habitat; such information is fundamental in the implementation of a fishery improvement project. Around the world, different methodologies have been developed to generate information on the impacts of the fishery on the ecosystem; one of them is modeling based on the Ecopath program with Ecosim.
The civil organization COBI used this tool including information generated by fishermen and fisherwomen of our community (Punta Allen) through fishing logs, as well as biological and ecological information for the species that inhabit the fishing zones. In addition, to strengthen the model, the traditional ecological knowledge of our community was integrated through the application of interviews, from which relevant information was obtained about the diet of the species, their geographic distribution, reproductive season, etc.

  1. The fact that fishermen and fisherwomen are generating information on fisheries through fisheries monitoring.
  2. It is important to integrate the traditional knowledge of fishermen and fisherwomen, since they have a large amount of important information about their natural environment and species.
  3. The results must be shared with the people of the fishing community, so that they value and appropriate their knowledge.
  1. The process to obtain the results from the modeling (by Ecopath with Ecosim) can take about six months, since it is necessary to search for information, interview people in the community, analyze the information and make the models.
  2. It is important to socialize with the fishermen the importance and benefits of knowing the effects of the fishery on the ecosystem, and to let them know how their traditional knowledge is integrated in order to obtain more robust information for ecosystem management.
  3. The interviews conducted with the fishermen to record their traditional knowledge were long (approx. 40 minutes), which sometimes made them lose interest on the part of the interviewee. In addition, with respect to the time needed to conduct each of the interviews, the availability to interview more members could be scarce.
Co-management in the sustainable Caribbean lobster fishery in Bahia Asención, Mexico

It has been recognized that collective efforts and/or well-organized groups with a common vision and aligned objectives achieve greater benefits. This same principle has been used to promote sustainability in fisheries, adding multisectoral participation as a central axis; thus having a group integrated by various sectors of the region working together to have a sustainable fishery throughout the value network. In the lobster fishery, a broad group of fishermen and fisherwomen have formed strong alliances with research institutions (ECOSUR, Cinvestav, UNAM, SISIERRA, Universidad Marista), civil organizations (COBI), government (INAPESCA, CONAPESCA and Reserva de la Biósfera de Sian Ka'an) and the FAO to implement various improvements in the lobster fishery.FAO to implement various improvements in fisheries (fisheries monitoring, define reference points for fishery limits, participatory establishment of minimum size, exchanges between cooperatives and marketers, generation of savings funds) and thus make better decisions. These collaborative relationships have been formalized through various agreements and/or conventions that have allowed the relationship between institutions and fishing organizations in accordance with the changing needs of the fishery.

  1. Integration of all sectors that may be involved in the fishery; leaving no one out ensures the path to sustainability.
  2. Transparency about the objectives and interests of each sector generates more robust and long-lasting alliances for continued collaboration.
  3. Organization among fishermen and fisherwomen, academic institutions, government agencies, and CSOs, since spiny lobster in the Caribbean is a resource of high economic value that is immersed in a complex network of stakeholders.
  1. It is necessary to identify the areas of opportunity in the fishery found under the MSC standard assessment and jointly generate an action plan, in which each of the stakeholders involved can become involved due to their common interests.
  2. Close follow-up on the progress of the action plan and the agreements established with all the sectors involved (fishing organizations, government agencies, academic institutions, CSOs) strengthens the credibility of the project and generates trust for the achievement of common objectives.
  3. Constantly monitor the needs identified by fishermen and fisherwomen regarding the social and financial, management, and environmental aspects of the fisheries, in order to address challenges in a timely manner.
  4. Having strong governance within and of the fishing organization improves knowledge about the benefit to the fishery and decision making (e.g., internal regulations, sanction process for non-compliance with norms, laws, and/or assembly agreements).
Community collaboration and involvement

Collaboration with the local population has been a major factor in the success of anti-poaching operations, and must be maintained in order to strengthen confidence and build up the sources of intelligence essential for well-targeted actions in the Protected Areas (PA).

The objective of restoring public confidence in the security and defense forces (FDS) and creating a climate of serenity was 100% achieved under the project. The mixed units not only had access to eco-guards from the communities, but were also able to interact with the local population, exchanging ideas and restoring their confidence. This contact between the mixed units and the local populations was a unique opportunity that should be repeated.

Contact cells (intelligence cells) from the communities were also set up, with the overall mission of infiltrating the area covered by the PONASI complex in order to detect any suspicious poaching or criminal activity, and to quickly pass on information, process and analyze it, and initiate action or have it initiated.

  • Community participation in anti-poaching operations with village-based eco-guards,
  • Community participation in information-gathering operations through village-based community intelligence networks.

Ongoing inter-action between mixed anti-poaching units and local populations ensures better coverage of the landscape and faster results in protecting and securing Protected Areas.

Men's training

Training was a key factor in the success of anti-poaching operations.

The different elements did not have the same working procedures, the same work rhythm or the same rigor.

The men all received technical and tactical training, as well as knowledge of wildlife and the forest environment. This training was highly beneficial, enabling the men to reinforce their knowledge in various fields (forest combat, combat first aid, IST, ISTC, navigation, operational motorcycle driving, camp defense, logistical and operational mission preparation, RETEX, etc.). A total of 10 operational training modules are delivered each time a force projection is planned.

The capacity-building achieved through the operations supported by the project should be maintained for future operations, as it fosters close collaboration and a climate of trust between the various units deployed.

  • The same training for all planned units,
  • Better coordination,

When the components of mixed units receive the same training, everyone knows their role better, and command and action in the field are more effective.

Strong involvement and collaboration with government services in the implementation of a joint anti-poaching ap-proach.

Throughout the project, the involvement and collaboration of the administrative, military and paramilitary authorities representing the State has enabled the launch of large-scale joint anti-poaching operations capable of dissuading any desire to occupy the Protected Areas, given the level of insecurity.

This strong involvement of the State has enabled the various local security actors (FDS) to come together around the same table, bringing them to federate their efforts to achieve common goals.

The army's full collaboration in these kinds of activities is essential, and was a reality in the context of this project, enabling all members of the mixed units to be equipped with protective gear, weapons and ammunition.

- Bringing together the various players in local security (FDS) around the same table,

- Logistics and pooling of resources (financial, material and technical),

- Coordination of activities

The logic of a global approach combining the forces available is adapted to the specific terrain of Protected Areas, enabling the reconquest and complete control of these protected areas, which are still too often inaccessible, a necessary condition for securing the wider landscape.

Increase community awareness and involvement

This project encouraged the participation of youth and community volunteers to gain support and increase local knowledge of the importance of protecting local ecosystems. Increased community involvement will work to build capacity while empowering and strengthening local conservation efforts. The group of volunteers we currently work with is a mix of residents and visitors, men and women, young and old and from a wide range of backgrounds.

Efforts are made to keep policymakers involved and inform them of the importance of mangroves in general and restoration in particular to gain their support. 

 

  • Supportive community, whenever activities are anounced they respond readily

  • the actvities organised for engaging the community are diverse (tours in the mangrove forest, events, presentation evenings) and thus cater to a variety of groups like school groups, junior rangers, general public, science community and stakeholders operating in the area. 

  • Easy access to media outlets.

  • Momentum reached (having reached a lot of local, regional and international exposure).

  • Collaborating with other nature organisations helped reach more people.

  • Advertisements for events could be improved by divulging information through other media channels, e.g. radio.

  • Organising different forms of outreach activities, such as public presentations, encouraged community engagement.

  • Even though most residents speak English, communicating in both the local language and English gives a better result.

     

Reforestation in degraded and sparsely vegetated areas

Enhancing the conditions in the degraded areas,  eleminating threats in the mangrove forest will lead to natural regeneration. However the restauration can be sped up by using nursery grown saplings. New plants from the nursery are used in degraded areas and along the coast to support reforestation efforts. Expanded mangrove forests will form a first line of coastal defense for extreme weather conditions and rising sea levels, supporting an ecosystem-based approach to climate change adaptation and mitigation on the island. This also includes a pilot program to encourage regrowth of mangroves in degraded areas and demonstrate intervention method success.

  • There was a ready supply of saplings from the nurseries.

  • Planting mangrove saplings could be done by anybody and was a good activity to raise awareness. Outpanting events always raised enough volunteers in the community

  • The availability of propagules and good functioning nurseries provided enough plants for the outplanting efforts.

Initially, plastic pots and bags were used (see block 2). The use of biodegradable bags decreased transportation space and handling of the saplings, thus increasing survivability.

Creating Market Linkages and Promotion of Eco-Friendly Leather products

Community livelihood initiatives have to be linked to market and promotion for them to be sustainable and provide a financial impact that they have been designed to bring forth. 

 

When building the capacity of a community to produce eco-friendly items, there is a need to establish a very good foundation of how these products will reach the market but also what are the demands in the market when it comes to quality criteria. Leather items in particular especially items made with Naturally tanned leather stand a chance in the market, however they need to meet high quality standards and be promoted so as to enhance consumers to know of their existence. For this solution initiatives were taken to assess the market for Leather products in main cities such as Nairobi town, Arush Town and even Zanzibar to identify shops or dealers who would be willing to purchase the products. 

 

Promotion of the products in different platforms is also very key through catalogs, social media and participation in fairs/exhibitions. Market linkages and promotion is a bridge for the community livelihood initiatives to bring financial benefits and make communities willing to continue the production chain.

  • Marketing Linkages and Promotion of Eco-Friendly leather products have been made possible through a market assessment conducted to identify dealers/supplier/potential buyers as well as to identify the types of items and their demand in the market.
  • Social Media promotion and participation tourism Fairs have attracted Lodges and Camps to order items for their curio shops.
  • Through the Marketplace Literacy program designed by OIKOS EA, the beneficiaries were able to receive additional training on consumer knowledge, quality production as well as marketing skills. 
  • Market Linkages and promotion of community based Eco-Friendly products is a very important step toward attaining sustainability of any livelihood program. Communities will continue to engage in these activities if they receive financial gains and see their lives being transformed. For sustainability to be realized, a lot of time and financial investment is needed to support the communities to be able to produce products at a high standard and meet both local and international market demands.
  • Business skills and Financial Management skills are also very crucial to form part of the livelihood diversification programs. Many community livelihood programs fail due to lack of business mindset and proactiveness  of the members to take charge of their business. Financial mismanagement has affected the commitment of community members to continue with the initiative leading to high levels of dropouts and hence less production. Proper engagement and commitment of  the community is a success factor for any livelihood initiative.
Training and Cross Border Learning Exchanges

Eco-Friendly Leather Tanning and Manufacturing knowledge is an upgraded concept of curing naturally hides and skins from livestock. The initiative targets  vulnerable women who are illiterate and have limited opportunities as well as skills. 

 

Training has been tailored to specifically reach these target beneficiaries using simple instructions and toolkits as well as a more practical approach. The training has been conducted in Maasai language mostly and Kiswahili in other cases. The simple methods of measurements and cutting has proved to be adaptable and understood even among the illiterates. For most women, this has been one of the only formal skills they have received in their lives. Most importantly, during the training a set of skills were identified among beneficiaries and nurtured in the followup sessions. 

 

The first Learning exchange done where women from Kenya traveled to Tanzania and learned in an established Leather Center was a remarkable turn and it created a huge impact in how they received the initiative. They were very eager to have more women in their country trained and benefit  from the activity. The knowledge and skills offered have changed the mindset and transformed the livelihoods of women.

The training design, methodology and practical exercises were some of the best experiences that made this initiative possible. Capacity building for women who have little or no formal education can be a challenge. The training was designed to accommodate this need and make the women understand the concept but also choose to be part of what they are more capable of. For example, older and illiterate women were more focused on beading the leather products such as belts, while some who have some formal education were more engaged in measuring and cutting belts.

  • Training and capacity building has to be tailored to suit a specific context, needs and demands of the target beneficiaries. Language, culture and the fact that women also take such a huge role in their families every day need to be taken into account when deciding the training plan.

  • The learning exchange between peer groups/ women is very powerful in transforming mindsets and creating passion. The cross-border learning exchange can be expensive but it is worth setting out a clear plan and budget that will make this journey educational and interesting to the participants.

  • It is essential for anyone who is interested in conducting community training and capacity building to take time in designing a relevant content, methodology and even dedicate half of the time to practical exercises. It is also equally important to take into account all other cross cutting issues such as gender roles, language, distance, and levels of literacy. 

Stakeholders Engagement and Partnerships

The Leather Tanning and Manufacturing for women has been made successful through stakeholders engagement and partnerships. Among the key stakeholders includes the government representatives who have played a key role from building the concept, selecting the beneficiaries, participation in the training and making follow-ups for the leather centers. Access to a building to be equipped has been possible through this collaboration. The District Community Development officials have taken a clear role to monitor and supervise the women groups, assist them in registrations and even provide access to market during any events/fairs organized by the government.

 

Other key stakeholders include private companies, lodges, individuals in the areas who have provided markets for women’s produced goods. 

 

The implementing partners to the project including ZSL and SORALO have been supportive in ensuring that the solution is rolled out successfully in Kenya as it was in Tanzania. They carried the role to ensure that OIKOS EA is introduced in the communities in Kenya and they have enabled good flow of communication with the government in the project area.

Good collaboration and communication has made this support possible. All stakeholders were clearly engaged at the early stages and they had a buy-in of the idea. They have been willing to support the idea and to create a conducive environment for team members to work.

In the course of implementing the solution, we have learned that Stakeholders engagement is very key in the success of any project activity. Good communication and regular updates have facilitated the effective engagement of the stakeholders. It is important to identify the stakeholders at early stages of project design and implementation so they can also assist to give their input on how to be successful. 

 

The major challenge of engaging government officials sometimes is budget implications  and defining the frequency of such engagement. It is important to have an idea of how much budget is available and how many meetings/visits that the budget can cover so as to plan better. Sometimes there is a lot of bureaucracy that comes hand in hand with engaging stakeholders, each wanting to skew the ideas/solution to their best interest. Its is very crucial to have a constructive engagement and determine clear roles of each stakeholder from the beginning. In some cases, it is recommended to sign Memorandum of Understanding and have the roles clearly written down.