Community-based aquaculture
The purpose of this building block is to provide Blue Ventures’ partner community members with new sources of income, allowing improved access to food and education, while alleviating pressure on fisheries and marine biodiversity. Working with the University of Toliara’s marine science institute (IHSM), local seafood exporter Copefrito and aquaculture company Indian Ocean Trepang (IOT), Blue Ventures is connecting isolated coastal communities in the Velondriake LMMA with lucrative international markets for seaweed and sea cucumbers, enabling families to develop their own aquaculture businesses. Blue Ventures’ aquaculture specialists have trained over 700 people to become farmers of sea cucumbers (Holothuria scabra) and red "cottonii" seaweed (Kappaphycus alvarezii). In partnership with CITE, a Malagasy NGO supporting local socio-economic and entrepreneurial development, they also help to nurture small business development with training programmes that build the technical, financial, managerial and organisational skills needed by fishermen and women to manage their own aquaculture businesses.
Partnerships with a marine science institute, local seafood exporter and aquaculture companies are fundamental to this initiative. The sea cucumbers are initially reared in hatcheries in the regional capital, and the juveniles are then transferred to community-run pens and grown out until they reach commercial size, when they can be harvested for international export to Asian markets. The technical inputs and market demand accessed through these private sector partners is crucial to the functioning of this initiative.
Blue Ventures has found this community-based aquaculture programme to be a highly effective in providing communities with new sources of income, allowing improved access to food and education, while alleviating pressure on fisheries and marine biodiversity. Over half of the farmers supported are women, who are able to use their new income to help pay for children’s school fees and supplement their family’s diet. Challenges relating to high levels of juvenile sea cucumber mortality following transfer to lagoonal enclosures are being addressed through culling of predatory crabs and technical improvements to pen design, which have been successful in increasing survivorship from 40% to 77%. Loss of sea cucumbers through theft is a major challenge as these are highly valuable with numerous traders and wild stocks are severely overexploited. Farmers are tackling this problem by constructing watchtowers to monitor pens, and implementing a rotation system of night guarding.
Mangrove reforestation
Shrimp farmers are obligated to develop and implement a mangrove reforestation plan within their production area; they pay community members, often women, to garden the mangroves, including re-planting.
tba
tba
Broad discussion of the community rules with the community
Strong communication efforts (exchanges, meetings, popular debates, interactive radio in local languages) throughout the process of establishing and operating Kawawana. This has given fruits, as today other community conserved areas have been created close to Kawawana and more are in progress. .
Only available in French. To read this section in French, please download the document "Blue Solution Template in French: ‘L’aire du patrimoine communautaire KAWAWANA: La bonne vie retrouvée par la conservation’” from the bottom of this page, under 'Resources'.
Only available in French. To read this section in French, please download the document "Blue Solution Template in French: ‘L’aire du patrimoine communautaire KAWAWANA: La bonne vie retrouvée par la conservation’” from the bottom of this page, under 'Resources'.
Formulation and implementation of waste management bylaws
The community group identified in building block 2 together with a selection of village leaders is trained in bylaw formulation and implementation. Topics covered in the training include government structures in Tanzania and types of laws and regulations; concept and fundamentals of local government; management of natural resources at village level; Tanzania legislation related to waste management; meaning of bylaws; regulations that guide formulation of bylaws; process of local bylaw formulation; approval of formulated bylaws at district level; and implementation of approved bylaws (including opportunities and challenges). The training process enables the group to conduct a detailed analysis of the current status of waste management in their communities and understand the expected impact of poor waste management if it is not well considered in the bylaws. Understanding the process of bylaw formulation and approval also helps participants to recognize the existing management and administrative gaps between the district council, village council and community members so that an effective strategy can be put together to address the gaps and build a strong co-management approach.
Support and commitment from village government for formulation, implementation and enforcement of waste management bylaws, support and action from District Legal Team for the bylaw approval process.
It is of considerable benefit (but not essential) to invite a police officer to participate in bylaw training to provide advice and guidance on the practicalities of law enforcement and judicial processes and to build relationships between trainees and law enforcement authorities.
Monitoring and evaluation
Monitoring and evaluation (M&E) are vital components of every Pride campaign, without which assessment of the effectiveness of the intervention cannot be conducted. M&E takes place in every component of the Theory of Change (please refer to the building block 'Theory of Change' for a brief description of each component). Monitoring keeps score on how effectively capacities are built, how effectively social marketing efforts lead to changes in behavior, and if those behavior changes lead to desired conservation outcomes. Monitoring basically tracks every component of the ToC. M&E of knowledge, attitude, interpersonal communications and behavior change is based on pre and post campaign surveys of the fishers, while threat reduction and conservation results use specific protocols validated by experts.
• Having a local monitoring partner or consultant is key to develop timely baseline data and monitor threat reduction and conservation results. • As with any project or program, having adequate and sufficient funding is key. Teams may rely on existing human, equipment, facilities, and financial capacities to reduce costs. • Sites with long term tradition of monitoring are better suited to produce a solid baseline of biological monitoring indicators.
An important lesson related to biological monitoring is when there is the possibility of having a two person team for each campaign, a Campaign Manager (CM) and a Fisheries Fellow (FF). This arrangement allows for one person to concentrate on the fisheries technical aspects, including the necessary time for biological monitoring. The level of involvement of the FF in the monitoring component depends on his/her personal inclination towards science. There are examples where the FF devoted a considerable amount of time and effort to conducting monitoring and analyzing data, while others did not participate at all. This could improve with a clearer definition of the FF’s role in regards to biological monitoring. Having a person dedicated to monitoring in Rare’s team ensured all fisheries campaigns had baseline and post campaign impact data.
Rehabilitation and strengthening of traditional rules
Assertion of community collective rights and capacity to govern (decide and implement decisions) and manage (provide surveillance, monitor) its heritage territory Re-establishment of ancient rules (for instance, no entry in the zones where the spirits live).
Only available in French. To read this section in French, please download the document "Blue Solution Template in French: ‘L’aire du patrimoine communautaire KAWAWANA: La bonne vie retrouvée par la conservation’” from the bottom of this page, under 'Resources'.
Only available in French. To read this section in French, please download the document "Blue Solution Template in French: ‘L’aire du patrimoine communautaire KAWAWANA: La bonne vie retrouvée par la conservation’” from the bottom of this page, under 'Resources'.
Mangrove management plan
Based on official fishing and environmental regulations such as periodic closures, bans and minimum sizes, the management plan contains a detailed programme for resource use, control and surveillance and monitoring and evaluation. Every illegal activity is reported to the overseeing government body.
tba
tba
Collaborative science
Accurate and updated information is crucial for resource management. Forming Technical Groups enables collaborative science for decision making. These groups consist of participants from public and academic institutions who meet regularly to share information relevant to the fishery’s management.
- Access to public fishing data - Collaboration through expert meetings - Clear mechanisms and rules to share and use information of different sources and by different institutions - Clear roles and responsibilities for every expert group member - Analysis and not only dissemination of information - Scientific information shared with decision makers - Sharing information on fisheries with the communities to increase sense of ownership and involvement in joint monitoring
- Trust between government institutions, scientists and civil society organisations is key to enable an exchange of information - Up-to-date information on fisheries allows better decision-making regarding management activities, helps to recover or conserve species and to calculate more accurate Maximum Sustainable Yield-levels and individual allocations - Community involvement in data collection supports the empowerment of community members and establishment of a responsible relationship with the resource - It is important to publish the results of every investigation in which the community has been involved to create transparency as well as to motivate them to continue in joint monitoring
Collection of historical and geographical information
Catch data from the last centuries collected from research institutes, libraries and maritime museums, and through surveys.
Only available in French. To read this section in French, please download the document "Blue Solution Template in French: ‘AfricaSaw, Réseau d’alerte/sauvegarde du poisson-scie, Afrique de l’Ouest’” from the bottom of this page, under 'Resources'.
Only available in French. To read this section in French, please download the document "Blue Solution Template in French: ‘AfricaSaw, Réseau d’alerte/sauvegarde du poisson-scie, Afrique de l’Ouest’” from the bottom of this page, under 'Resources'.
Fine-tuning site management
Legalize locally managed marine areas (LMMA) at district and provincial levels. Implement an initial 2-year management plan to be regularly revised. Regular monitoring and reporting includes annual meetings of all members involved in co-management. Consider climate change adaptation of livelihoods in ongoing interventions and the management plan, as well as changes of state mechanism (staff and capacity) and emerging local needs. Mobilize funding from institutions and organizations.
• Support from the local authority who is legally governing the administrative area where the LMMA is located for mobilizing participation of other state and non-state actors • Active support and participation of the community • Support of a non-governmental organisation and seeking the necessary funding for complementary activities to be included into the LMMA plan.
Capacity building, skills development and strong institutional arrangements are important to successfully manage and monitor LMMAs. Vietnam’s LMMA initiatives benefit from the commune experience where cooperation was gradually extended to other stakeholders, including management bodies at district and provincial levels. This approach was successful for local support and to create linkages and networks at national and regional levels. The district People’s Committee maintained the co-management board and the district’s annual budget allocation after the project ended in 2005. Nevertheless, sufficient long-term funding remains a challenge. Therefore, sustainable financing mechanisms that generate revenues from the LMMA’s ecosystem services should be created.