Thematic groups representative of the fishing sector

During the COVID-19 pandemic, the Fishermen and Fisherwomen's Network was created as a space for collective action with the intention of ensuring a space for participation, organization and representation of the fishing sector. Since its formation, the Network has sought to ensure the representation of the sector by bringing together diverse actors, both individuals and community organizations and groups. Each member voluntarily participates in thematic groups focused on areas such as monitoring of fishery resources and environmental conditions (community monitoring and oceanographic monitoring group), improvement of fishing practices (fisheries group), inclusion of youth and promotion of gender equity in fisheries (youth and gender group), and valorization of the sector through (community photography group).

Each thematic group develops work plans aligned with the Network's mission and values. So far, these groups have played a crucial role in raising the visibility and recognition of the fishing sector, actively participating in national and international meetings to disseminate its values and promote actions in favor of sustainable fishing. In order to join a thematic group, interested persons must fill out a form, which will be evaluated by the core group for integration.

1. Strengthening of capacities and skills focused on the interests and needs of each thematic group.

2. Collaboration and exchange of knowledge and experiences among the members of the thematic groups.

3. Linking with people outside the Network (fishermen, fisherwomen, civil society organizations) to mobilize community solutions.

4. The work plans of the thematic groups are designed in a group and consensual manner by the members of the thematic groups and are aligned with the objectives of the Network.

5. To make visible the work carried out by coastal communities in Latin America and the Caribbean.

6. There is a form to integrate new people to the thematic groups of the Network, once completed, the core group reviews the applications following the established criteria and defines the status of the application (approved or not).

  1. The participation of different people from different regions and communities, as well as from different fisheries, represents the diversity and generality of fishing in Mexico.
  2. The willingness of people to participate on a voluntary basis in the thematic groups and activities programmed in the Network is remarkable. For the proper functioning of volunteer work and coordination with the Network's activities, it is important to take into consideration aspects such as people's work schedules or fishing seasons due to availability issues.
  3. Communication between the thematic groups is essential for the proper implementation of the Network's objectives, the mobilization of community solutions, the transfer of knowledge, and the creation of innovative ideas for the benefit of the fishing sector.
Forming governance bases for the effective participation of the fishermen's and fisherwomen's network

The Fishermen and Fisherwomen's Network has developed a governance system designed directly by its members, which includes various elements to foster transparency, communication, collaboration and effective participation. It currently has a core group composed of at least one representative from each thematic group (currently there are six thematic groups: youth, gender, oceanographic monitoring, community monitoring, community photography and fisheries). These representatives are responsible for communicating and interconnecting the activities and discussions of their groups with the other members, thus facilitating integration and cooperation within the network.

In addition, the Network establishes clear processes for selecting and integrating new members, which strengthens its governance structure. This strong governance, including well-defined rules, objectives and procedures, has been instrumental in fostering continued participation and exchange of experiences among participants.

The Fishers' Network has consolidated a participatory and transparent governance system focused on collaboration and communication among its members. This not only strengthens internal cohesion, but also drives the achievement of their shared objectives in an effective and sustainable manner.

Diversity of fishing communities represented. 2.

2. Constant effective communication between thematic groups and the core group to promote participation and representativeness of the fishing sector.

3. Autonomy in the systematization and documentation of processes.

4. Shared responsibility among members for decision making, execution of work plans and calls for collective action by the fishing sector.

5. Transparency in decision making within the thematic groups and core group.

6. Revision and updating of the Network's statutes.

Creation of a shared vision by and for the coastal fishing sector.

The participation of different communities and age groups provides a more complete and complex vision of the fishing sector.

Importance of having clarity in processes such as: admission of new members to the Network, roles and responsibilities of representatives of thematic groups in the core group, commitments of each thematic group and objectives of the Network of fishermen and fisherwomen. This certainty in the processes encourages the participation of the people who make up the network.

Respect and correctly execute the work plan built collectively, always maintaining the vision of the members of the Network and its thematic groups.

Generate collective impact through the activities and call to action of network members.

Haenggung Village Cooperative Association

The local residents who were previously excluded from the various cultural tourism activities and festivals centering on the World Heritage property started to independently host village activities and built up their capacities for delivering and managing events. 

The initial residents group started to participate in the operations of the Suwon Heritage Night Walks in 2017 as traffic control staff. As the number of festivals that were hosted to celebrate Suwon Hwaseong as World Heritage increased, such as the Hwaseong by Night, World Heritage Festival, and Media Art Shows, the number of jobs available for the residents also increased. 

The Haenggung Village Cooperative Association was established on 31 May 2021 and it consists of 46 members. The main line of work is creating content and activities for visitors. 
The association is composed of 4 sub-groups each named “jigi”, which in the Korean language means friends: 

  • Haenggungjigi, who focuses on providing event support, information, sanitation and the operation of activities; 
  • Donghaengjigi, a group that creates the content and stories of the village tours; 
  • Surajigi that promotes and shares research and education on food; 
  • Cheongnyeonjigi, the group that monitors and conducts evaluations of activities. 

It was key to create jobs that could best optimize the capacities of the local residents. The division of work between members of Haenggungjigi, Donghaengjigi, Surajigi and Cheongnyeonjigi was fundamental to organize the work. 

Lastly, all residents participating in these activities had to complete a mandatory training.

Through the cooperative association that based itself on the experience of creating village activities, diverse jobs that could be directly linked to the capacities of the local residents were set up. These included positions such as event operation staff, information officers, cooks, and conducting baseline research. This made a big transition as the residents who were previously neither part of nor benefitting from the festivals could now directly be involved and be paid for their contributions. 

The mandatory training for the residents who wanted to participate increased the overall capacities of the local residents and boosted their understanding of World Heritage, local values and  the importance of local participation. 

Haenggung Village Cooperative Association

The local residents who were previously excluded from the various cultural tourism activities and festivals centering on the World Heritage property started to independently host village activities and built up their capacities for delivering and managing events. 

The initial residents group started to participate in the operations of the Suwon Heritage Night Walks in 2017 as traffic control staff. As the number of festivals that were hosted to celebrate Suwon Hwaseong as World Heritage increased, such as the Hwaseong by Night, World Heritage Festival, and Media Art Shows, the number of jobs available for the residents also increased. 

The Haenggung Village Cooperative Association was established on 31 May 2021 and it consists of 46 members. The main line of work is creating content and activities for visitors. 
The association is composed of 4 sub-groups each named “jigi”, which in the Korean language means friends: 

  • Haenggungjigi, who focuses on providing event support, information, sanitation and the operation of activities; 
  • Donghaengjigi, a group that creates the content and stories of the village tours; 
  • Surajigi that promotes and shares research and education on food; 
  • Cheongnyeonjigi, the group that monitors and conducts evaluations of activities. 

It was key to create jobs that could best optimize the capacities of the local residents. The division of work between members of Haenggungjigi, Donghaengjigi, Surajigi and Cheongnyeonjigi was fundamental to organize the work. 

Lastly, all residents participating in these activities had to complete a mandatory training.

Through the cooperative association that based itself on the experience of creating village activities, diverse jobs that could be directly linked to the capacities of the local residents were set up. These included positions such as event operation staff, information officers, cooks, and conducting baseline research. This made a big transition as the residents who were previously neither part of nor benefitting from the festivals could now directly be involved and be paid for their contributions. 

The mandatory training for the residents who wanted to participate increased the overall capacities of the local residents and boosted their understanding of World Heritage, local values and  the importance of local participation. 

Review - identify fire issues and options for change

Once we have established a Community Wildfire Management Team we review their local wildfire issues and identify options for change using a range of participatory methods. Our aim is to build an understanding of how and why fires start within each community and the positive and negative impacts of fires started for different reasons, and in different areas. We recommend interviewing various people including members of the Community Wildfire Management Team, other village leaders and elders, women, youth, and local authorities.

When we understand the causes and impact of wildfire we then conduct community mapping to spatially determine: 

  • where fires are most likely to be lit and why;
  • potential firebreaks or control lines within the landscape;
  • location of water sources;
  • location of access roads and tracks;
  • priority areas for protection (e.g. high value forest and restoration areas); and
  • the ability of local community members to control fires both through pre-suppression and suppression measures.

These fire maps helped each community implement measures to prevent, detect, and effectively respond to wildfire.

A successful review of wildfire issues requires:

  • The completion of Building Block 1 - Community and Government Engagement before undertaking the review process.
  • Gaining a wide range of perspectives about wildfire within each community, as communities will have different drivers, responses, and attitudes to wildfire.
  • Understanding why wildfires occur, particularly if they are lit to benefit some people, is crucial in managing their damaging impacts.

In reviewing the causes and consequences of wildfire on the Tonle Sap Lake we learnt that:

  • Wildfire is caused by people, and most are deliberately lit.
  • Hot, dry weather is a significant driver of wildfire. And wind is the major factor in spreading fire.
  • In communities without fire suppression equipment rainfall is the main factor in extinguishing fires.
  • We recommend printing and prominently displaying each community’s annual CBFiM plan so that it serves as a constant reminder of wildfire management and planned activities.

 

Data collection, reflexion, and adaptation for sustainability with relevant partners

The data collection and ongoing monitoring of the project's achievements were carried out by a dedicated Monitoring, Evaluation, and Learning (MEL) team. This team, external to MUVA, conducted in-depth interviews, focus group discussions, and periodic analysis of each action plan at baseline, midline, and final stages. This systematic approach allowed for comprehensive data collection, culminating in a reflection meeting at the end of the initiative. Facilitated by a senior facilitator, results were presented to the MUVA, Aquapesca, and Pro Azul teams. The meeting provided an opportunity for teams to extract key learnings and formulate a path for scaling and sustaining the initiative.

  • Budget for an external MEL team allocated for the project
  • Aquapesca availability to engage in the MEL data collection process
  • As the project is highly innovative and tailored, some of the success indicators are developed during the definition of action plans. Consequently, the MEL team's involvement in mentoring sessions allowed for the creation of indicators aligned with actions and the periodic monitoring of results. This approach promoted motivation and agility in the execution of plans by observing the progress of the initiative.
Developing the Regional Ocean Governance Strategy through a co-creation process

The ROGS Support Team supported a diverse WIO ROGS Task Force, involving state and non-state representatives from various sectors and organisations. This inclusive forum facilitated stakeholder dialogue and collaboration, with members providing inputs directly to the ROGS and expanding regional contributions by inviting stakeholders from their networks. The Task Force, along with key stakeholders, contributed strategic and technical insights to the ROGS through Technical Dialogues and regional events.


The Collective Leadership Institute (CLI) supported the Task Force through in-person workshops and online sessions  to enhance collective leadership and collaboration. An experienced ocean governance advisor, Mr. Kieran Kelleher, played a key role in formulating strategy questions and compiling ROGS content.


The inclusive and participatory approach aimed to foster ownership, improving the quality, feasibility and credibility of the ROGS. If adopted at the next Nairobi Convention Conference of Parties, this ownership is expected to boost the strategy's implementation.

 

  • Clear process and goal outlined in the process architecture for drafting the ROGS together

  • Participant interest and openness for individual and collective contribution

  • Capacity development and process stewardship prioritized by CLI, emphasizing authentic participation, trust-building, and co-creation

  • Technical dialogues led by the Task Force, engaging sector-specific stakeholders and experts for a shared understanding and optimal policy recommendations

  • Weekly online meetings of the ROGS Support Team, organized by CLI to ensure a high-quality process

  • Need to assign clear roles within the process including someone who drives the process forwards according to set timelines

  • Both process leadership and technical leadership

  • Consideration of financing and resourcing as an integral part of the ROGS

Political will and mandate to develop a Regional Ocean Governance Strategy

Political leaders of the WIO countries have recognised that cooperation among regional organisations and across sectors, including greater engagement of the private sector and civil society, is required to address growing regional challenges such as marine and coastal conservation, marine plastic pollution, climate change, response to disasters like oil spills or cyclones etc.


A series of successive policy processes, including the 2015 call by African Union (AU) for the development of an African Regional Ocean Governance Strategy through the Cairo Declaration of the African Ministerial Conference on the Environment (AMCEN), the 2017 Libreville Declaration of AMCEN, and a baseline study on WIO Ocean Governance, led to the mandate for the development of WIO’s Regional Ocean Governance Strategy at the 2021 Conference of Parties to the Nairobi Convention (NC) (Decision CP.10/5). In response, the Nairobi Convention Secretariat convened a Support Team to help guide a participatory development of the WIO ROGS by working with representatives of the NC Contracting Parties, the AU, the WIO’s Regional Economic Communities (RECs), the Indian Ocean Commission, private sector and civil society actors in a Regional Ocean Governance Strategy Task Force.

  • Having a high-level political mandate is an important success factor for engaging in a multi-stakeholder, participatory process for regional strategy development

  • Selection  of Task Force members by countries, the AU and the RECS, and thus country participation in the creation of the strategy

  • Financial support from regionally endorsed projects and partners

  • Coordinating and covening ability of the NCS

  • Long process leading to the adoption of the decision in 2021 and protracted preparation period due to the wide scope and diversity of sectors and themes

  • Coordination of such a regional and political process requires continuous capacities on all sides and a strong will to participate actively

  • Continuity and a long-term process for developing and implementing strategy needs to exist before the start of the process

  • Ability to frame questions and issues in a form leading to consensus through technical dialogues

  • Effective feedback to the TF on consensus positions

Develop a Follow-Up and Monitoring Plan

The objective of this building block is to provide technical teams with parameters for measuring the effectiveness of restoration actions in the field.

The monitoring plan should include elements to evaluate the following parameters: 1) degree of development of planted species and their response capacity, 2) changes in water patterns and abundance, 3) changes in biodiversity dynamics (presence and abundance), as well as in the disappearance of exotic and/or invasive species, 4) changes in the environmental conditions of the area, and 5) changes in land dynamics and use, as well as public use and community demands.

  • Social auditing favors accountability in the quality and quantity of public investment in the territories.
  • Co-administration or co-management agreements favor accountability in the quality and quantity of non-governmental investment in the territories.
  • The creation of local governance platforms favors the creation of robust and transparent accountability systems.
  • The data provided by the monitoring system should have a technical component (how have we progressed in the restoration of our area?) and a social component (what are the monetary and non-monetary benefits of the investments made?), so that the actors involved maintain a real and effective interest in contributing to the restoration of these sites.
step-by-step implementation

the new site management approach will be implemented progressively, in stages. The corresponding deliverables will be proposed and discussed by the site's Scientific Committee and the Natura 2000 site's COPIL.

In order to gradually adapt an exemplary conservation management approach to combat habitat closure, specific studies have been carried out to assess the effectiveness of mowing and grazing, based on changes in vegetation and flora taxa since at least 2010. These studies were based directly on multi-taxon inventories carried out at regular intervals on the marsh. These elements are taken into account in the site's 2023 action plan.

Consequently, short- and medium-term management actions have been identified. In the short term, it is planned to carry out selective clearing and crushing of the overgrown areas (grazed area), with export of the cuttings. Similarly, it is proposed to maintain mowing techniques in the northern zone.

In the medium term, it is recommended to continue ecological monitoring of the conservation status of open environments (every 5 years), as well as monitoring of heritage flora and entomofauna.