Monitoring and empowerment of IGAs

This corresponds to the individualization phase of the IGAs. Each member, having identified the activity that corresponds to him or her, breaks away from the group and sets up on his or her own. Close monitoring and evaluation of the IGAs developed by these communities is carried out with the aim of refining members' knowledge of their respective activities and minimizing production losses.

Overall, it enabled us to identify any shortcomings that had not been observed during the implementation phase:

- Communication on the progress of activities

- Proximity to markets and major towns, to enable crops to be sold off

- Optimization of cucumber yields

Among other things, the general objectives were to

- Allowing communities to choose with whom they would like to work in pairs.

- The transfer of experience from other members of neighboring villages on how to monitor an IGA.

Setting up income-generating activities proper

- Training and supply of inputs:

Training is provided by professional consultants in the field (SEMAGRI), and consists of building members' capacities in agropastoral techniques according to the chosen activity. AVEC then used their own funds to purchase the inputs they needed to develop their activities.

-The development of school/experimental fields: these are test areas where the training received is put into practice. Depending on the activity, there were school fields for agriculture and school farms for livestock. These areas are managed by the community and the profits are paid back to the group. These fields also enable members to identify the activities they would like to pursue.

Involvement of all beneficiaries (members of the IGA group) in the fieldwork phase.

Contribute to the development of alternatives linked to fishing and hunting activities in the Douala-Edéa landscape.

Stimulate the green entrepreneurial spirit in each learner.

Community collaboration and involvement

Collaboration with the local population has been a major factor in the success of anti-poaching operations, and must be maintained in order to strengthen confidence and build up the sources of intelligence essential for well-targeted actions in the Protected Areas (PA).

The objective of restoring public confidence in the security and defense forces (FDS) and creating a climate of serenity was 100% achieved under the project. The mixed units not only had access to eco-guards from the communities, but were also able to interact with the local population, exchanging ideas and restoring their confidence. This contact between the mixed units and the local populations was a unique opportunity that should be repeated.

Contact cells (intelligence cells) from the communities were also set up, with the overall mission of infiltrating the area covered by the PONASI complex in order to detect any suspicious poaching or criminal activity, and to quickly pass on information, process and analyze it, and initiate action or have it initiated.

  • Community participation in anti-poaching operations with village-based eco-guards,
  • Community participation in information-gathering operations through village-based community intelligence networks.

Ongoing inter-action between mixed anti-poaching units and local populations ensures better coverage of the landscape and faster results in protecting and securing Protected Areas.

Identification of income-generating activities (IGAs)

Proposals and development of IGA projects take place after the AVEC has been in operation for one year, in order to ensure that the group is cohesive. Meetings are organized with the AVECs to list the IGA proposals they would like to undertake. It's important to emphasize that the approach used must be down-top (proposals are not imposed by the project), in order to reinforce the adhesion and appropriation of the project by the members. On the basis of their proposals, an analysis is made to identify the activities best suited to the local context.

Financial planning is important and can help to improve the business, as it indicates whether or not profits can be made and requires improvement within the group. Two plans are imperative for business planning:

-The sales and costs plan (making a monthly forecast of sales and costs for the year).

-The cash flow plan (helps you to know in advance each month's cash inflows and outflows, and provides assurance of its availability).

  • Orienting the choice of AGRs with short production runs
  • IGAs must have a low investment rate
  • Let communities choose IGAs according to their social context
  • The opinion of all those involved must be taken into account to avoid any future inconvenience in the event of failures during the implementation phase.
Men's training

Training was a key factor in the success of anti-poaching operations.

The different elements did not have the same working procedures, the same work rhythm or the same rigor.

The men all received technical and tactical training, as well as knowledge of wildlife and the forest environment. This training was highly beneficial, enabling the men to reinforce their knowledge in various fields (forest combat, combat first aid, IST, ISTC, navigation, operational motorcycle driving, camp defense, logistical and operational mission preparation, RETEX, etc.). A total of 10 operational training modules are delivered each time a force projection is planned.

The capacity-building achieved through the operations supported by the project should be maintained for future operations, as it fosters close collaboration and a climate of trust between the various units deployed.

  • The same training for all planned units,
  • Better coordination,

When the components of mixed units receive the same training, everyone knows their role better, and command and action in the field are more effective.

Strong involvement and collaboration with government services in the implementation of a joint anti-poaching ap-proach.

Throughout the project, the involvement and collaboration of the administrative, military and paramilitary authorities representing the State has enabled the launch of large-scale joint anti-poaching operations capable of dissuading any desire to occupy the Protected Areas, given the level of insecurity.

This strong involvement of the State has enabled the various local security actors (FDS) to come together around the same table, bringing them to federate their efforts to achieve common goals.

The army's full collaboration in these kinds of activities is essential, and was a reality in the context of this project, enabling all members of the mixed units to be equipped with protective gear, weapons and ammunition.

- Bringing together the various players in local security (FDS) around the same table,

- Logistics and pooling of resources (financial, material and technical),

- Coordination of activities

The logic of a global approach combining the forces available is adapted to the specific terrain of Protected Areas, enabling the reconquest and complete control of these protected areas, which are still too often inaccessible, a necessary condition for securing the wider landscape.

Establishment/creation of Village Savings and Credit Associations

It consists in bringing together community members and creating mixed and free groups according to their social preferences. AVECs are created in villages whose populations more or less meet the following criteria: proximity to protected areas, potential impacts of community activities in protected areas, importance of the community in the circuit of movement of goods and people, their willingness to take part in the project. Once most of these conditions have been met, the team meets the community with the permission of the traditional authorities, and a community mobilization meeting is scheduled.

During the meeting, the project's objectives are presented to them, and they are given a period of reflection so that they can re-examine the project and decide whether or not to join. If they decide to join, the team accompanies them through the process of setting up the AVEC, which operates as follows:

- Weekly or monthly meetings at their convenience

- A statute and rules of procedure are drawn up

- A board of 5 to 7 members elected each year

- AVEC has 15 to 30 members

- Loans with interest are authorized

- Savings and profits are distributed to members in proportion to the shares saved.

These include

  • The approval of local authorities for this new community bank model
  • The mobilization of traditional chieftaincies to bring community members together at consultation meetings.
  • The availability of communities for this new type of community savings model
  • The involvement of more women in exchange meetings
  • Leave it up to the communities to choose the members of their group.
  • Always take into account the social context of intervention before setting up this kind of community bank mechanism, because in one of our intervention areas, whose communities are heterogeneous in terms of population, there was a strong presence of expatriates such as Nigerians, Malians, Ghanaians and Cameroonians. The creation of AVEC community banks has not been successful in this locality, due to the non-stability of the members of this population.
  • The interest generated by the loans must be shared equitably to avoid conflicts between group members.
  • The importance of living in a community to promote solidarity and mutual aid.
Increase community awareness and involvement

This project encouraged the participation of youth and community volunteers to gain support and increase local knowledge of the importance of protecting local ecosystems. Increased community involvement will work to build capacity while empowering and strengthening local conservation efforts. The group of volunteers we currently work with is a mix of residents and visitors, men and women, young and old and from a wide range of backgrounds.

Efforts are made to keep policymakers involved and inform them of the importance of mangroves in general and restoration in particular to gain their support. 

 

  • Supportive community, whenever activities are anounced they respond readily

  • the actvities organised for engaging the community are diverse (tours in the mangrove forest, events, presentation evenings) and thus cater to a variety of groups like school groups, junior rangers, general public, science community and stakeholders operating in the area. 

  • Easy access to media outlets.

  • Momentum reached (having reached a lot of local, regional and international exposure).

  • Collaborating with other nature organisations helped reach more people.

  • Advertisements for events could be improved by divulging information through other media channels, e.g. radio.

  • Organising different forms of outreach activities, such as public presentations, encouraged community engagement.

  • Even though most residents speak English, communicating in both the local language and English gives a better result.

     

Reforestation in degraded and sparsely vegetated areas

Enhancing the conditions in the degraded areas,  eleminating threats in the mangrove forest will lead to natural regeneration. However the restauration can be sped up by using nursery grown saplings. New plants from the nursery are used in degraded areas and along the coast to support reforestation efforts. Expanded mangrove forests will form a first line of coastal defense for extreme weather conditions and rising sea levels, supporting an ecosystem-based approach to climate change adaptation and mitigation on the island. This also includes a pilot program to encourage regrowth of mangroves in degraded areas and demonstrate intervention method success.

  • There was a ready supply of saplings from the nurseries.

  • Planting mangrove saplings could be done by anybody and was a good activity to raise awareness. Outpanting events always raised enough volunteers in the community

  • The availability of propagules and good functioning nurseries provided enough plants for the outplanting efforts.

Initially, plastic pots and bags were used (see block 2). The use of biodegradable bags decreased transportation space and handling of the saplings, thus increasing survivability.

Relevance and concordance of social impact assessment (SAPA) and management effectiveness assessment (IMET) results

The assessment of social impacts was based on a participatory method that involved first consulting local communities on their perception of the impacts linked to the existence of the protected area, then carrying out an in-depth analysis of these impacts through a survey of a sample of households, and drawing up an action plan. At each stage of stakeholder consultation, a report is made to the consulted stakeholders on the results obtained and the next steps to be taken. The IMET evaluation involved the same stakeholder groups as the SAPA evaluation, but in smaller numbers and using a different method based on a series of evaluation questions. At the end of the process, each assessment produced action proposals based on the gaps identified. Although conducted by different teams and using different methods, most of the actions proposed by the two assessment methods were similar. This reflects the quality of the investigations carried out, as well as a sound methodological application and analysis of the results. We can also conclude that these two methods, although one addresses social impacts, the other management effectiveness, can be complementary in the evaluation of protected areas.

The rigor of the evaluation method was decisive in obtaining the results. In fact, although the assessment methods were different, each with its own stages and methodology, similar conclusions were reached regarding the actions to be implemented as a result of each assessment. It must also be said that the experts' in-depth knowledge of the site involved in the assessments enabled them to draw up an accurate assessment of the situation, and to propose actions that were certainly appropriate.

As far as lessons learned are concerned, we can say that it is important, when implementing protected area assessments, to call on specialist assessors who, in addition to their methodological knowledge, have a certain mastery of the protected area management context, in order to provide finer-grained analyses in line with local realities.

We also believe that in the context of community protected areas, IMET assessment alone is not enough to identify management priorities. The strong presence of communities in this type of protected area means that the social well-being of local communities must be taken into account to ensure effective overall management of the protected area.