Securing long term land-use rights for the community and conservation objectives

Clear land ownership and land tenure (the right to use land) are the basic preconditions for the implementation of any habitat management measure. Land-use rights of all beneficiaries needs to be clear and secure before project initiatives commence to avoids risk of undocumented dimensions in the planning and implementation of conservation measures. It also secures long-term interest of the land user to manage the land sustainably. The purpose of this measure is to clarify, legally regulate, obtain and hold land tenure rights needed for conservation actions and for sustainable livelihood. Land tenure rights encompasses land ownership, lease of land and/or other rights related to the use of land. 

 

In Georgia, most land is state owned. But after the breakdown of the Soviet Union land tenure rights have not been properly documented or registered. Today, traditional land-use rights based on verbal agreements and traditions are translated into legally documented/registered leases by the CBOs representing their respective villages. Resolving uncertain land tenure is one of the major benefits the ECF is bringing to partner communities, providing them with a clear economic perspective for the future while preserving the existing community management of shared pastures and meadows. 

  1. Readiness of state property authorities to document and register the existing community land use rights 
  2. Completion of a land tenure study to understand the land tenure uncertainties and existing rights 
  3. Accurate mapping of entire conservation area and communication of these findings (maps, figures, reports) accessible to the community and authorities
  4. Active involvement of local governments (municipality and department levels) 
  5. Voluntary involvement of local authorities, departments and administration
  6. Proper compensation for land-use
  • Properly identify land-use rights and open issues including research, data collection and GIS analysis performed i) formally (municipal and regional data collection), and ii) informally (discussions with locals).
  • Consideration of information documentation and lack of documentation. Locals may use pasturelands/meadows in a traditional way, with little or no documentation of their user rights. In the frame of the project, the land-use needs to be considered in both formal/political contexts and informal/traditional contexts. 
  • Communication between multiple land management bodies in Georgia (state, municipality, community, private) and land-use designations (forests, agricultural, protected areas, private land). Positive relationships and active communication with all stakeholders leads to healthy working relationships.
  • Consideration of national and regional politics integral to securing land-use rights. 
  • Sufficient budgeting of costs required to obtain land-use rights.
Establishment of community-based organizations (CBOs)

Establishing a CBO is the step between the FPA process and signing a Conservation Agreements. CBOs are created with ECF’s guidance and are responsible for:

i) securing and implementing a Conservation Agreement

ii) the fair and equitable distribution of benefits among the community

iii) acting as the legal entity representing the community in a Conservation Agreement.

CBOs are formed under the national law that is appropriate to its purpose, country and region. If creating a CBO is not possible, an NGO can act as a CBO in the Conservation Agreement. 

 

To establish a CBO requires the local community to make a long-term commitment to cooperation and take responsibility for conservation actions. In this way the CBO contributes to strengthening the social capital and increasing sustainable land-use practices. CBO’s help build community connectedness, communication and resilience related to nature conservation efforts. CBOs are encouraged to consider biodiversity as part of the local economy and work closely with ECF toagree on sustainable land-use. CBOs are encouraged to seek other sources of funding for community projects and to develop their activities as a sustainable business during the implementation period of the Conservation Agreement. 

  1. Self-organisation of communities is initiated or strengthened through the FPA 
  2. Negotiation of terms with representatives of the community to provide a clear, long-term Conservation Agreement 
  3. Dialogue, negotiation and involvement with all segments of the community: elders, decision makers, influential community members, women and youth
  4. Identify and include all user groups within a community: herders, farmers, hunters, healers
  5. Involvement of local authorities (i.e.forest department)
  6. Strategic engagement with institutions at regional and national levels 
  • Lack of community level governance, lack of environmental awareness and negative wildlife interactions required education/community awareness campaigns.
  • Small, locally-led projects encourage community capacity building, communication and implementation of conservation strategies.
  • Establishment of CBOs represents FPA progress and a qualitative improvement in terms of local self-organisation.
  • Do not impose an organisation model on the local community; decide on a model together.
  • Capacity building related to management and governance of CBOs is critical to secure initial success and reduce dependence on external support.
  • Involvement of the CBO with acquisition and organization of baseline information on livelihood-related issues, natural resources and land-use secures relevant information and contributes to CBO’s capacity building.
  • Accepting community members’ views when designing project goals ensures project serves entire community.
  • Involvement of local governments link the applications of ecosystem-based management to larger themes like climate change and disaster risk reduction.
Water conservation measures (water harvesting through contour trenches or terraces)

In Tajikistan, precipitation varies by season. In spring, precipitation is relatively high, while in the summer months are hot and dry. Irrigation water is provided through meltwater. Depending on the type of land use and local climatic conditions, different activities on harvesting and conserving water can be undertaken for making it available for annual crops.

Water from snow and rain can be harvested by installing contour trenches alongside contour lines or terraces. The trenches should be discontinuous and shifted, following a scheme of a chessboard. The trenches should be dug with 1m width, 1.5-2m length and 0.5m depth. This method has several important benefits:

  • Enables water infiltration, making it thus available for annual crops
  • Prevents the water run-off
  • Averts  soil erosion, soil degradation, gullying and landslide
  • Increased water retention is especially important for cultivating rainfed annual crops as these cannot receive artificial irrigation and thus depend on the water reserves in the soil.
  • Climate change entails more water stress for annual rainfed crops and thus increases pressure for implementing water harvesting and conservation measures.

Many farmers do not have their own tractors and contract owners of tractors for ploughing their land. These frequently do not want to plough contour lines, alleging that the strain for the engine is higher, till the point that the axle could break. As a consequence, it is better when the owners of the fields acquire single axle tractors by themselves or as a group for installing contour lines or terraces in their fields.

Diversified crops (oil crops specifically important for rain-fed fields)

Planting different annual crops in a particular order over several years on the same field, also known as crop rotation helps to ensure long-term soil sustainability as the crops have different requirements in terms of nutrients. This prevents the accumulation and propagation of soil-borne diseases and pests. In Tajikistan, many farmers prefer cultivating the same cash crops, e.g. cereals in rain-fed areas, instead of applying crop rotation as in short-term this produces more income. In order to avoid the long-term negative effects, oil crops (flax, sunflower, and safflower) and pulses (chickpeas, green peas, and lentils) can be used to promote crop rotation and diversification. Pulses fix nitrogen and thus improve soil fertility. Crop rotation can be combined with the no-tillage practice for having an even better effect.  

An example of a three-year rotation could be:

-  Year 1. Cereal crop, e.g. winter wheat

-  Year 2. Legumes, e.g. lentil, chickpea

-  Year 3. Oil crop, e.g. safflower 

Rotation of annual crops with perennial fodder plants as alfalfa or esparcet may also be considered, as these have a very positive effect on soil fertility.

  • Many farmers noticed that their harvest is decreasing and infestation by pests and diseases increased in their rainfed fields if they are continuously cultivating cereals and therefore are eager to try crop rotation.
  • Oil crops and legumes attract pollinators, improve family diets and are marketable.
  • Some species of oil crops and legumes as safflower and lentils need only a little water for growth and are resistant to high temperature, therefore they are resilient to climate change
  • Special machinery should be available for cultivating alternative rainfed annual cops, e.g. single axle tractors with sickle bar for harvesting oil crops as safflower
  • In case of oil crops which have to be processed as safflower it is necessary to produce a certain amount of harvest so that transportation to a mill is worth it.
No-tillage

The traditional technique of soil cultivation in Tajikistan using a plough or a disc for breaking and turning the soil's surface leads to a loss of fertility by the destruction of organic matter, reduced capacity for water retention and soil erosion, especially on slope areas. Therefore, soil cultivation within fields of rainfed annual crops should be limited to a minimum. In order to prevent the negative effects of the traditional cultivation methods, farmers are encouraged to apply the no-tillage or low tillage techniques. When applying the no-tillage technique, the soil is not disturbed as only a small slot is opened for collocating seeds and eventually fertilizer. When applying the low-tillage technique, the soil is cultivated superficially with discs but not turned at all as it occurs by ploughing. Both techniques can be applied by using a single axle (two-wheel hillside) tractors which are promoted by the project. No-tillage or low tillage must be carried out along contour lines on slope areas.

  • Preparing the field with no-tillage or low tillage technique costs less than ploughing as less fuel is required.
  • The no-tillage technique increases the content of organic matter in the soil, thus fertility, water infiltration and retention capacity. 
  • Less seeds are required as these are collocated directly on the spot and not broadcasted as in the traditional technique.
  • The infestation by diseases is reduced as the plants are in line and the wind can blow better through the stand and dry the leaves after rain or dewfall.

Nevertheless, the no-tillage technique requires specialized equipment which in many cases is still not available in the country, positive experiences were seen in other projects using single axle tractors equipped with no-tillage gear. For a better result and safety, the single axle tractor should be driven by an experienced operator and the owner of the field should clear the ground from stones.

Also, it should be noted that the no-tillage technique stimulates weed growth, at least for a couple of years, until a solid mulch layer can be built up to suppress the weeds. The use of herbicides should be avoided whenever possible. Weed control during this period should instead be implemented through hand weeding or row weeding using horses, donkeys or tractors.

Gully control and check dams

Rills develop easily on degraded, steep sites during heavy rains and eventually enlarge to become gullies. Often times the area for planting rainfed annual crops is crossed by gullies. The construction of check dams is necessary to control erosion and capture nutrients, silt and moisture. Either living or dead material can be used for the construction of check dams. Further, check dams should be reinforced by planting bushes and trees alongside the gullies. As the gullies normally originate above the planned plot, this area has to be considered as well. For living material, it is recommended to plant fruit trees and bushes. Investing in gully plugging and check dams is rewarding since it can generate some yield and income in the future. However, living material also attracts livestock; hence the area might need to be fenced.

  • This technique does not require specific skills and is low in terms of costs, as long as building materials are available locally and the farmers are willing to contribute with their labor force.
  • Shrubs, bushes and trees of local species as cherry plum, hawthorn, barberry, cherry silverberry etccan be planted for gully plugging which aside from preventing erosion will also yield edible fruits and produce firewood.
  • Gully plugging, and check dams reduce the risk of mudflows and potential floodings further downhill.
  • This technique is relatively labor-intensive to set-up and maintain and while not providing immediate benefits, therefore, farmers have to be convinced by the benefits.
  • Frequently one farmer family alone is not able to plug a gully, therefore, a collaboration of owners of neighboring fields might be required.
WHH
North and Central Asia
Deutsche
Welthungerhilfe
Diversified crops (oil crops specifically important for rain-fed fields)
Gully control and check dams
No-tillage
Water conservation measures (water harvesting through contour trenches or terraces)
WHH
North and Central Asia
Deutsche
Welthungerhilfe
Diversified crops (oil crops specifically important for rain-fed fields)
Gully control and check dams
No-tillage
Water conservation measures (water harvesting through contour trenches or terraces)
Intercropping

Intercropping is a planting technique that involves cultivating two or more crops at the same time on the same field. Intercropping will result in increased yields as the plants use the available space and nutrients more efficiently and help each other to develop. The associated crops should belong to different plant families, in order not to share the same pests and diseases and to have different requirements on soil fertility and nutrients and extracting them from different horizons of the soil. Intercropping creates biodiversity, which attracts beneficial and predatory insects. As flowering increases, intercropping also favors pollinating insects and thus beekeeping.

There are three basic classifications for intercropping: a) mixed cropping, which involves planting a variety of compatible plants together without any definite arrangement (eg. maize planted together with beans); b) row cropping or alley cropping, in which different crops are planted alongside each other in rows (eg. alternating rows of carrots and onions); c) temporal intercropping, in which a slow-growing crop is planted together with a faster growing one, which is harvested earlier, allowing the slow-growing crop to subsequently occupy the entire planting area (eg. potatoes and pumpkins). 

Intercropping increases diversity of products to be harvested and reduces the risk of complete loss of harvest by pests and diseases as these normally are host-specific.

Intercropping maintains soil fertility as nutrients are not emaciated unilaterally.

Intercropping increases biodiversity and thus beneficial and predatory insects are attracted.

Through diversified crops the flowering season is prolonged, which is favorable for beekeeping.

Farmers in Tajikistan tend to plant crops to narrow, hence crops interfere with each other in a negative way; the weaker ones are suppressed, the harvest per plant is lower and partial, and the potential of intercropping is not used adequately. When intercropping species it has to be ensured that each of the involved species has enough space for growing.

The water demand of the associated crops should be similar to provide adequate water to each of the species. 

Farmers are sceptical at times about intercropping, alleging that it will be difficult separating the products, e.g. oat and pea. Therefore, adequate mechanisms such as using different sieves for separating grains have to be introduced to the farmers.

Water saving irrigation techniques

Irrigation by gravity (furrow or surface irrigation) is the main irrigation technique used in Tajikistan for annual crops. In order to avoid erosion the irrigation should be made by furrows which are following slightly inclined contour lines. The water influx should be slow, so as to increase water infiltration into the soil and reduce the risk of erosion along the irrigation furrow. Furthermore, measures should be implemented to make irrigation by gravity more effective, e.g. by lining irrigation channels with plastic foil for reducing water loss through infiltration or by distributing the water to the furrows by plastic pipes for achieving a homogeneous allocation.

Special attention should be paid to avoid too much watering; excessive water should be evacuated properly as it can cause soil erosion, the formation of gullies or attract pests.

In a gravity irrigation system, it is crucial to break the soil surface between the furrows in order to destroy capillaries and thus preserve humidity.

More sophisticated and efficient irrigation techniques as drip and sprinkler irrigation are economically not viable in most cases in annual irrigated crops.

Water is a scarce resource in Tajikistan and the situation is worsening with population growth and in the wake of climate change. Therefore, farmers are interested in implementing water saving irrigation techniques. The means of choice is improving irrigation by gravity as in most cases it is too expensive to install drip or sprinkler irrigation systems for annual crops.

Many farmers are irrigating annual crops by gravity, letting the water simply flow downhill and are not aware that such a procedure causes erosion. They should be trained on implementing furrow irrigation following contour lines.