Community beach clean-ups
We regularly organize beach cleaning-up campaigns at weekends, especially during vacation periods with students, to collect plastic bags and garbage. We communicate with the community through the local community radio and public events.
Creating a partnership with the environmental department of the city hall to take waste to its final destination.
The involvement of the community in solving their own problems is very inspiring and positively contagious. It improves the impact. However, I would advice a very efficient communication in order to not leave anyone out. All members of the community should feel useful in the process.
Integration of fisherfolk
Fisherman are addressed in their work place in informal conversations aiming to raise awareness on the impacts of their behavior. They are also regularly invited to participate in training sessions in which scientific data is shared. This expresses the need of changes in their behavior. We share scientific data such as conservation status of loggerhead turtles as an endangered species due to plastic ingestion, ocean pollution and other human actions (UICN). We also share information such as the prediction by the Ellen MacArthur Foundation and the World Economic Forum that “there will be more plastic than fish in the sea by 2050” if we do not change our behavior.
Fishermen are simple and humble people and can be easily accessed as they are members of the same community as the solution providers. After gaining their trust they become good solution partners.
Local fishermen are very knowledgeable people and their experiences are very useful and should be taken into account. Their daily activities provide them useful information that has been used to improve the solution. They know where the threats are stronger and where sea turtles are more vulnerable to hunting. Their knowledge has also assisted us in determining the best time of the day the sea turtles lay eggs, the main spots and the period of hatchings.
Success through involvement of local communities
The community is divided into 2 groups, children and adults. The children regularly participate in beach cleaning campaigns on weekends and help taking sea turtles hatchlings to the sea. Adults participate in harder work such as beach night patrols and collecting plastic from the sea.
Some members of the community are part of the solution. It facilitates carrying messages to the community and solves problems. By having a person from the community on our side inspires more confidence and brings more people together.
Any environmental project cannot succeed without the involvement of the local community. They are the people who better know their community. By engaging them you make sure the project continues in the future and is passed to the next generations. They should be involved in decision making, planning and the implementation of actions.
Multifactor diagnostic chart
This building block helps to identify the factors that threaten sea lion populations with a spatially-explicit, multifactorial approach. The outcome is a set of prescribed actions for each population in the same geographic realm, depending on their diagnostic characteristics, avoiding an “all-purpose” general, possibly ineffective solution. For each colony or population of sea lions, a set of environmental factors is selected and described with a historical perspective. Examples of relevant factors are: sea temperature, upwelling index, pH, chlorophyll, diet composition of sea lions, microbial load, heavy metals. Next, a group of drivers are identified as influencing the region of interest and for a given year, their influence in factors is determined and qualified. Drivers can be: ENSO, climate change, over-fishing, pollution. The end result could be that only a few or several colonies could be affected, even in the same geographical region or sub-region.
1. Information about population: total number of individuals; numbers of pups; numbers of females, diet information for sea lions, pollution data. 2. Availability of environmental variables. All the time series of environmental variables were fetched from internet specialized public sites.
Because this Building Block requires a fair amount of data, some basic information might not be available. At the end, using a data-poor approach, one has to use a set of available environmental variables, namely temperature, chlorophyll and upwelling.
Data from landings and fishing surveys
Surveying fishermen allows a valuable insight to what is being landed across Morocco - and in what quantities, if species are effectively reported and if not why not, what methods are being used to catch elasmobranch species and if species are being heavily targeted for commercial purposes or simply by-catch. Through this we have understood that many fishermen have little or no knowledge of laws and restrictions on shark/ray species and that many international and national trade/catch policies are not translated from management level to the fishermen themselves – who are unaware they are breaking laws. We are therefore working with artisanal fishermen to establish the beginnings of a species education program and on basic training in DNA data collection from their landed catches.
The most important element is communication. We had two translators on our volunteer team, French and Arabic speaking, which ensured that information was taken correctly. Every team member has to understand the situation they are faced with when meeting and discussing with fishermen. E.g. if a large protected species is being landed and sold –it is not appropriate to question the fishermen aggressively or to get in the way of their work, as this simply cuts of their desire to communicate with us
In the future we hope for this to be made easier in some localities by obtaining more official sanctions from the fisheries ministers and port authorities – as many fishermen in Morocco can feel un-easy with women and scientists asking questions unless they are with a port official, however this is only the case in 1 in 5 ports. Photography is often frowned upon in ports due to either religious beliefs or simply concerns with sanitation and officials worrying that they are being monitored on health and safety standards. It is always polite to ask before taking photographic evidence – however in certain circumstances it is necessary to obtain data – and this is usually a judgement call by the team or individual present.
Citizen shark scientists
Volunteers are trained to conduct genetic sampling and necropsies and to gather data by monitoring landings and surveying fisherman. This creates an opportunity for conservationists and concerned citizens to have a positive impact and learn new skills for the benefit of species conservation. This has also enabled the collection over a wide area of a vast amount of viable data for scientific studies. Ultimately it means that Fin Fighters are able to provide a much needed data resource in data deficient areas for poorly understood populations. The participants are trained to ID species from various body parts and to take ID images for our data bank. Some of our volunteers request to be taught more in-depth collection skills such as sampling either in situ on the ports, or in controlled environments. Others further their involvement by learning how to carry out necropsies and to extract samples of specific material – such as sperm, or stomach contents for later study. The volunteers (or Citizen Shark Scientists) are also taught how to survey fishermen, and fishing equipment, and to understand fishing methods.
It is important that volunteers work well in a team and in high pressure situations to collect data that is controlled and that all reporting is carried out in a reasoned manner – without assumption. Many of our volunteers have skills that can be useful in an investigation – such as a second language, or a past working in the fishing industry, this enables communication with fishermen and officials easier and helps to build confidence within the voluntary team.
We have learnt that working in this way requires a great deal of patience and understanding of the different ways people process information. It has led to tailoring different learning activities to fit individual’s needs and in doing so has also taught us new techniques of describing the practical elements of our work. Whilst Fin Fighters operate a democratic and fair approach to our investigative process – including every member’s opinion in our decision making; It is also necessary for the investigation for the director to maintain a leadership role throughout. Ensuring every members voice is heard is important, but this then needs to be translated in to cohesive action and managed in a safe and proficient way – we found in the field that having a leader in final decision making and implementation way key to the success of the investigation process.
Transparent sharing of information
The results of the project have been shared with Belize’s Ministry of Forest, Fisheries and Sustainable Development (including Coastal Zone Management Authority and Institute and National Climate Change Office) and the Ministry of Tourism to facilitate replication, and uptake of the process and recommendations. The results have also been shared with local communities, local NGOs, land developers and the private tourism sector to build capacity, awareness and implementation of greener landscape practices within the coastal zone.
• Continuous and transparent sharing of information and best practices with communities and stakeholders. • Interest and wish to conserve the natural ecosystems exhibited by local communities, stakeholders and government decision-makers.
Working in partnership and building a sustained relationship with local communities and stakeholders (e.g. private tourism sector groups) on the Peninsula opened doors for us to influence better practices on the ground. This is very important since these groups can play important roles as advocates, sponsors, partners and agents of change. WWF has been carrying out conservation and climate adaptation related projects on the Placencia Peninsula since 2007, and over the years have built credibility within and among the communities and sectors on the Peninsula. Where there is trust, communication can be very effective.
Formative Research
During the planning phase extensive formative research informs the Social Marketing, as well as the Technical Assistance components of a campaign. Research sets the baselines that allow the assessment of social and conservation impacts following a campaign. Qualitative research (e.g. focus groups, observation, in-depth interviews) is geared towards understanding target audience opinions, feelings, concerns and perceived benefits of current as well as desired management practices. Qualitative research is about creating a casual conversation with and between participants to establish a comfortable relationship, and to reveal underlying information unobtainable through quantitative research. Quantitative research surveys capture specific answers to specific questions to describe demography, identify media preferences, and assess the current state of knowledge, attitude, communication and readiness of target audiences regarding a certain behavior change. Both components ultimately inform campaign decisions like objectives, respective activities, materials, and messages for both Social Marketing and Technical Assistance.
• Training on qualitative and quantitative research methods. • Generic qualitative research guide/procedure to support researcher in preparing and during research rounds. • Templates to facilitate qualitative research analyses. • Quantitative research (i.e. survey), following best practices for survey question design to avoid bias in respondent answers. • Committed base of volunteers to support survey implementation. • Software to process and analyze quantitative data.
Qualitative research techniques (e.g., focus group and in-depth interviews) geared towards understanding the target audience opinions, feelings and concerns regarding a certain behavior change are essential to create casual conversations for participants. This enables creating an environment of trust in which fishers feel comfortable expressing what they really think instead of expressing what others want to hear. The latter would make data barely reliable. Surveys that are built on qualitative research results tend to better inform campaign strategies, making them more aligned with campaign goals and objectives. It is essential to avoid setbacks when it comes to survey implementation, and detailed planning based on sample sizes and human resources is necessary. In that sense, building strong relationships with a committed group of campaign volunteers to support this task is essential.
Working toward a marine protected area (MPA)
This is the essential building block toward creating an effective MPA at the Costa Rica Dome. It is still In process. The steps already taken are stimulating, through conferences and meetings, discussion at national, regional and international levels. This process was started by presenting the idea with a case study in Marine Protected Areas for Whales, Dolphins and Porpoises (Hoyt, 2011) and an associated campaign, and, crucially, working closely with the Central American (Costa Rica based) NGO MarViva.
: In process; obtaining further funds to facilitate meetings and lobbying
Need ABNJ legal structure for high seas MPAs
Cost-benefit analysis
Alternative adaptation options were analyzed via the Marine InVest tool to identify costs and benefits of these approaches. Costs were incorporated directly into the scenarios and InVEST. This included the costs of implementation of adaptation options combined with any associated costs to ecosystem services quantified by our models, and benefits represented by the positive return in ecosystem service values quantified by our models. Local experts helped in reviewing the selected ecosystem services and adaptation options. A technical report was developed on the activities.
The models had the capacity to effectively quantify the potential costs and benefits of climate change and alternative adaptation strategies to lobster fishing and coastal protection, and alternative adaptation strategies to tourism and carbon storage and sequestration. The ecosystem service models provided a useful framework for tackling a complex set of issues within limited timeline.
Using storylines, spatial scenarios for Integrated and Reactive adaptation approaches, three models for ecosystem services, model for seawall protection from storms, information from the literature, and stakeholder expertise, we were able to effectively quantify the benefits of adaptation options in terms of revenue from lobster and tourism, carbon storage and sequestration, and avoided damages to coastal infrastructure. Outputs from models are relevant to Belize’s decision-makers, the public and private sectors, as described in building block 5. This CBA approach helped to clearly assess the costs and benefits of alternative adaptation options in an efficient way. Standardizing both costs and benefits, such as ecosystem services, in monetary values enables cross-sector decision-making and allows for a more complete economic assessment of options.