Empower local teachers through capacity building
All teachers and principals are trained with much care at the beginning of each school year. A workshop for 3 days is conducted to guarantee that the lesson plans, sessions and activities will have the utmost impact. We go though all sessions with the participants and also conduct all outdoor activities and experiments planned for the children. Together, we improve games, songs and theater plays.
Participation, motivation, engaging and enthusiastic trainers, good materials, nice training environment (we conduct training workshops outside for direct relevance to the material being discussed as well as a comfortable, healthy environment for participants).
The first school year showed that teachers and school principals needed to be trained intensively because their capacities were not enough to teach the program. They were happy for the extra effort and advice on how to teach well so that they could engage their students better. The skills they acquire during this training workshop can also be applied to the other disciplines that they also teach the children as part of the regular curriculum.
Indigenous-run tracker training school
The community is working to set up an indigenous-run tracker training school which would service Namibia and potentially also neighbouring Botswana. Due to low literacy levels in the region, indigenous peoples were previously kept out of formal conservation employment or underpaid for their sophisticated skills. Though anchored in Khwe traditional knowledge, the training and assessment methodology is based on international standards and is accessible to people from any background who have sufficient biodiversity and faunal / floral knowledge of a specific ecosystem. Research thus far indicates a strong demand for certified trackers by both government and private sector for conservation, anti-poaching and natural resource management.
The Khwe community has the first internationally certified trackers and assessors able to work with low literacy communities. Namibia has a national framework of Community Conservancies where trackers can be employed for wildlife conservation purposes. The Namibian government is open to setting national qualifications standards but this still needs to be developed independently and proposed to the national government.
Tracker assessment and certification helps address the bias and valorizes knowledge held in the community.Training school has been slowed down by resource constraints and the absence of a national capacity building framework to support decentralized training and certification for trackers and traditional knowledge holders.
Institutional Innovation
Two levels of institutions were established. At the Park level, an independent society was created that people could approach comfortably and a flexible management approach could be adopted. At the community level, Eco Development Committees (EDC) were created that would set up and manage revolving fund to provide loans on easy terms to members to get out of debt trap.
Please contact solution provider for more information
Evidence gathered through scientific designed performance assessment tool allows room for risk taking. Expanding the reach of conservation initiatives beyond the PA boundary is essential for realizing long term conservation goals.
Valuation of coral reefs and mangroves
Our economic valuation method can be repeated at relatively low cost, using largely existing data. We only valued a portion of the many services provided by coral reefs and mangroves, focusing on components that are relatively easy to measure using published information and especially important to local economies. Tourism: We used financial analysis to estimate that in 2007, reef- and mangrove-associated tourists spent US$150–$196 million on accommodation, reef recreation, and other expenses. Fisheries: We used financial analysis to estimate that economic benefits (sales plus value added from cleaning and processing) from reef- and mangrove-dependent fisheries were US$14–$16 million in 2007. Shoreline Protection: We evaluated shoreline protection services in a geographic information system (GIS). We used an avoided damages approach to estimate that coral reefs provided US$120–$180 million in avoided damages in 2007, with an additional US$111–$167 million from mangroves. In total, we estimated the value of these three coastal ecosystem services in Belize to be US$395–$559 million in 2007. As a reference point, Belize’s GDP was US$1.3 billion in 2007.
- Choice of appropriate valuation methods – we used financial analysis and cost of avoided damages. These methods are easily-understandable, straightforward, and replicable. The method also was cost-effective as it did not require any surveys to be administered (it relied all on secondary data). - Focus on ecosystem services that are relevant to decision makers - We chose three (fisheries, tourism, and shoreline protection) that are easily understood and are of immediate concern.
Our valuation approach – developed primarily for national level assessments – is only a partial fit at the MPA level. Because it provides a “snapshot” of today’s actual use, it gives artificially low value estimates for underutilized tourism sites such as Bacalar Chico. A study of tourism carrying capacity (dive, snorkel, fishing) for different marine sites in Belize would be useful to assess the full potential value of these sites.
Training in the use of GPS-capacity and IT data-base
In parallel with the formalization of the tracker skills and competence assessment, trackers learn to use Cyber tracker handheld computer / GPS technology. This allows important data on biodiversity trends and density, to be systematically recorded and algorithmic analyses provide rapid insight into conservation priorities, including issues of climate change, disease vectors and anti-poaching strategies.
Cybertracker technology was invented in Southern Africa and is specifically designed to support indigenous and local communitytrackers. The programming was influenced by the sophisticated knowledge of San trackers and then adapted to IT functionality. Trackers with little or no formal schooling can easily learn to use the technology. Cybertracker allows tracker observations to rapidly integrate detailed local knowledge and observations into scientific data diachronic and synchronic analysis
Introducing IT technology allows a better bridge between traditional knowledge and data management relevant to conservation goals. IT also validates traditional knowledge expertise and reduces the literacy biases. Young people are highly motivated to learn to use new technologies, encouraging intergenerational knowledge transmission and a virtuous learning cycle.
Science-based design
Best-available science was adapted to the local conditions in the form of research methods and field activities (i.e., approach to community-based mangrove replantation). Both scientific literature and local scientists were involved in the design and implementation of our approach. We drew from international and national scientific expertise and experience to design the areas that were to be deforested (aerial surveys, GIS mapping, satellite imaging), and the species to be replanted (depending on surveyed mangrove natural zonation). In addition, the approach to engage local stakeholders is based on similar recorded experiences in the Philippines. In relation to the Blue Carbon estimation, we used the methods agreed upon by an international group of Blue Carbon scientists, and these methods were implemented by local scientists. The estimation was directed by a scientific expert on the subject and followed international guidelines, and a botanist was hired to direct the mangrove replantation efforts.
· Existing work/trust relation with local communities · Existing national expertise · Local capacity
In general, stakeholder engagement was conducted with a high investment in time and the development of a broad collaborative (beyond project’s objectives) relation. The fact that the Blue Carbon estimations were made following a recognized scientific method facilitates publication, sharing and presentation of the results to international audiences and bodies such as the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) and United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC).
Ecosystem and biodiversity lesson plans and evaluation
12 Club P.A.N. sessions are held in outdoor nature classrooms. Sessions typically involve fact sheets, activities, role playing, songs and games with animal puppets which are based around a chosen theme. Themes deal with ecosystem services, wildlife conservation, sustainability, healthy living and the importance of biodiversity. We aim to promote positive club spirit through interactive ways of learning and essentially having fun.
Each child that participates receives his/her own Club P.A.N. book and T-shirt. Each child participates in pre- and post evaluation questionnaires which aid in refining sessions year after year to better suit the audience, as well as accrue funding for the project.
An extra lesson was added to the Club P.A.N curriculum in 2012 where children were given a small budget to carry out their own mini-conservation-project. They find this support incredibly motivating. Past project examples included planting trees, cleaning village water pumps, and even a goat farm.
Improved planning and coordination
Park authorities, communities and NGO’s developing a clearly articulated and agreed process to address issues. Land tenure and user rights secured for communities inside the park through participatory land-use planning and zonation with park authorities and NGO partners. Robust social institutions developed or strengthened to manage activities and decision-making in communities
Please contact solution provider for more information
The key lessons learned include, developing high levels of trust with communities and park authorities alike. This is best achieved by initially focusing on issues of shared concern, and building from there, and also ensuring all activities - be they non-governmental or community - are completely integrate into park management. Project proponents must spend significant time in communities and move at their pace and using their social institutions, where possible. When developing eco-tourism or other conservation enterprises, ensure a direct link between the income and the conservation – for example tourists only paying when they see selected species. To strengthen social institutions, and social pressure on compliance, payment schemes should include a community payment that is discretionary spending for the managing social institution.
Training in economic valuation
The bulk of our capacity building effort in Belize was aimed at enabling stakeholders to replicate our valuation methods. We focused at the MPA level, where we worked with a number of NGOs, as well as Hol Chan Marine Reserve and the Fisheries Department, to develop a template for applying the national valuation methods in MPAs. We worked with co-managers for several MPAs in Belize to compile data on use of the reserves for fishing and tourism. For many MPAs, this exercise highlighted gaps in current data collection, and drew attention to chronic undercounting of visitors and user fees. We produced preliminary valuations for all of the MPAs we worked with. We conducted a workshop summarizing our efforts in November 2008 and invited all organizations working on MPAs to attend. A great deal of interest was expressed in the economic valuation template. We have made it available electronically along with a detailed user’s guide. Several MPAs have already committed to adapting their current data collection efforts to better support economic analysis.
- Multiple training opportunities in different formats geared toward end users (workshops and one-on-one trainings)
The experience of training MPA managers in economic valuation drove home the important lesson that lack of time and high turnover rates make it especially difficult for many groups to replicate these studies; however, it did validate our belief that the method should be kept simple and straightforward, making it relatively easy to pass on the valuation techniques to new staff. We also feel that emphasizing collection of the relevant information for a valuation study (for instance, how many people are actually diving, snorkeling, or visiting the reef) can also lead to better management outcomes.
Active stakeholders across levels
We worked with local stakeholders at all levels of the project. Thanks to strong commitment from local women in particular, stakeholders, under guidance from an expert, took responsibility over the nursing and replantation of over 8000 mangrove plants. Local stakeholders were also engaged in capacity building for tourism microentrepreneurs, and an education program was launched at three schools. Prior clarification of the values and interests that motivate local stakeholders proved to be key in project design and implementation. Investing significant amounts of time working with and supporting the communities is critical to its success. In general, science was integrated throughout stakeholder engagement, including the education program. Specific activities include using current knowledge to present the value of mangroves to local children; designing and implementing the replantation program; and presenting the blue carbon assessments (i.e. scientific research) to local policy makers.
· Existing work/trust relation with local communities · High investment of field time/work and results monitoring · Local capacity
The success of this approach is rooted in the strong commitment of local women in particular and fishers from the island of Chira, in the Gulf of Nicoya. We invested significant amounts of time in the communities, working with them and supporting their work, instead of having them support “our” project. Prior clarification of the values and interests that motivate local stakeholders proved to be key in project design and implementation. We believe a field project has to understand and consider the interests and values of local stakeholders and include them into the activities that are being planned in order to achieve concrete, meaningful and durable results.