Protection and sustainable management of forests

The protection and sustainable management of forests within the biosphere reserve was accompanied by the active promotion of Participatory Forest Management (PFM) and integration of PFM user groups into the trade with wild coffee and honey. The following activities were conducted:

  1. Implement Participatory Forest Management in the region with the help of local authorities
  2. Record data on activities of NGOs active in the environmental sector in the regions Kafa, Sheka, Bench Maji, Yayu. Identify possible partners for the upscaling of the coffee & honey value chain
  3. Establish cooperation with Biosphere reserve authorities to strengthen PFM support within BR boundaries
  4. Assess the existing PFM user groups, analysing and recording their potential to supply wild coffee and honey and their administrative structures.
  5. Select existing best performing PFM user groups in wild coffee collection and honey processing.

The conservation aspect through the PFM aims at the sustainable use of the natural resource base and contributes as such to the preservation of biodiversity in one of the 34 internationally identified “biodiversity hotspots”.

  • Forest establishment and conservation, sustainable forest management and landscape rehabilitation is a national priority
  • National guidelines on participatory forest management (PFM) have been put in place
  • Kafa and Sheka received biosphere reserve status in 2009, a legal basis for protecting & managing forests
  • Exchange visits between biosphere reserves to learn and identify PFM options
  • Partnerships with other projects (e.g. GIZ and FarmAfrica) supporting biosphere reserves and PFM
  • Participatory Forest Management was introduced and proofed to be a useful tool for collaboration, co-management and benefit sharing of forest resources
  • Participation and ownership of local people in sustainable, long-term management of forests has been remarkably demonstrated at field level; communities invested time and labour, they participated in the planning process leading to empowered, legalized and derived benefits from the intervention approaches
  • Members of other cooperatives, who are not members of PFM groups still access forest area in the reserves; as their access is traditionally secured through the hereditary system, working with and training these cooperatives also contributed to forest protection even if not under the umbrella of the PFM system
  • For multi-stakeholder commitment within sustainable forest management system, government institutions need further strengthening to facilitate administrative support and conflict resolutions 
Cooperation between communities, private sector and development partners

The partnership was set up by using a multi-stakeholder approach involving a wide range of actors such as communities from the regions, private partners from Germany (Original Food), local administration and public authorities (e.g. Ethiopian Wildlife Conservation Authority) as well as partners from civil society (NABU, GEO Protects the Rainforest) and international partners (GIZ on behalf of BMZ). The partnership took advantage of the specialized know-how and networks of its members combining knowledge about local production, international quality standards, administrative procedures, capacity development and process advice.

 

A cooperative structure was set up jointly with local administrations helping farmers to export the forest products. Now, the majority of smallholders is organised in cooperatives and the project partners work closely with unions to establish a quality assurance system for the supply chains.

 

Both the smallholders and the employees of the cooperatives and unions receive trainings to extend their knowledge and take over the tasks in the new value chains. The economic activities were accompanied by several social projects such as family planning, youth centres HIV/AIDS prevention initiatives etc.

  • The initiative is in line with goals of government to preserve the country`s unique biodiversity and reduce environmental threats
  • Clear long-term interest and trustful relationship between Original Food with farmers, cooperatives and unions since 2003
  • Concept of economic incentive and protection through sustainable use of natural resources
  • Close collaboration with local population and entities
  • Broad knowledge and experience from all different partners combined
  • The mode of collaboration was highly innovative as it successfully created a linkage between economic regional development and environmental sustainability, between local population and attractive, long-term income opportunities through the protection of the rainforest
  • Today, more than ¼ of the PFM area is closely linked to the wild coffee trade, all 324 PFM user groups have additionally been trained to support the forest conservation
  • Direct cooperation between private companies and small-scale farmers helped to empower them and secure access to the European market
Partnerships for increasing productivity and better financial management

Clearly-defined and mutually agreed relationship between Johor State government through J-Biotech and Universiti Sains Malaysia (USM) in the Giant Clam project. Memoranda of understanding were signed twice during this partnership. The first phase of the Giant Clam Project (1998-2001) and phase two of the programme (2008-2011) has been succesfully carried out. 

 

Partnerships for increasing productivity and better financial management are shown through J-Biotech as Johor states represantative to provide financial, conservation area and manpower, while USM is known to champion mollucs breeding not only in the nation but also in the region.

 

The success survival of the juvenile of Tridacna Gigas has shown clear success for the juvenile to survive. Now, the juvenile has ready to breed. The next phase is artificial breeding. We are hoping for the chances of producing daughter populations.

1. APEX university

2. Skillful resource persons

3. Sophisticated equipment

Historically, Tridacna gigas is synonym with Johor and USM.  Conserving these giants are self explanatory on why we should protect our ocean. Choosing the right partnership wil save up unneccesary expenditure, both sides benefits in talent and human capital development. Both Johor and USM has long history of partnership and USMhas been very comitted to make the project as true sucess in conserving Malaysia's natural heritage. It is put aces in places . By forging strong collaboration with USM, it has prove to be successful for the next phase for Giant Clam conservation project in Malaysia. Johor is the only state in Malaysia, which has long commitment in restocked more than 900 three-year old clams (Tridacna squomosa) into its reefs in 1999, the first conservation effort of such in the country. Johor has been awarded the first island to produce giant clams for conservation by the Malaysian Book of Records.

Importance of conservation

Scientists, who have been monitoring the area before it was closed, estimate a 500% increase in biomass within the area since the closure. The area, previously covered with sea urchins, is now a thriving biodiversity hotspot with the balance restored. The elders report new species in the MPA that have not been seen in living memory. The coral, previously destroyed by human feet, has recovered quickly and the lagoon area is now known as one of the best snorkelling destinations on the Kenyan coast. Local and international students come and learn in our living marine classroom. Turtles feed on the seagrass beds undisturbed, and the number of nests has increased significantly. The area has returned from being a marine desert to a marine paradise and a critical model globally that shows how a poor community can help conserve nature and benefit from it too. Bigger and better catches outside the MPA has ensured support for the permanent closure.

 

The MPA could not have gone a head without the belief and forsight of the fisherfolk in the area and the acceptance to beleive that positive change was possible even in difficult circumstances. Local knowledge from the elders ensured a suitable site for the closure was chosen. Scientific research also supported the choice as having the most potential for long term improvement. Regular updates on improvements within the MPA has helped sure up the belief that it is successful as a breeding area.

That nature is resilient and can recover amazingly quickly if left alone to do so. Identifying needs and fostering willingness to embrace change can improve livelihoods. The importance of undertaking an environmental impact assessment on the area, underpinned by research and local knowledge, before the project started has been a critical factor towards the success of the MPA. Constant awareness and updates of the improvement in the MPA need to be communicated back to the community. Analysing the information can be used to put into perspective in the socio-economic impact. The importance of communication of our progress back to the community has been something we have had to improve. When the community understands and sees the benefits from change they are, understandably, more willing to accept it.

Growing juvenile clams in cages

The purpose of designing cage to be undertaken is to abate identified threats from predators.  Young clams are highly vulnerable to crabs (e.g. Thalamita spp., Demania spp.) that use their chelae to crush the shell valves; wrasses (Halichoeres spp.) feed on the byssus and foot of unanchored clams; and pyramidellid and ranellid snails are parasitic (Alcazar 1986). Tooth marks on the outer shell surfaces are indicative of attacks by grazing reef fish (Stasek 1965). For older clams, potential predators include eagle rays, turtles and large benthivorous fish (Bustard 1972; Govan et al. 1993), but their impact is reduced as the clams grow towards escape size (Adams et al. 1988).This is an explanation of why different cage design have been selected.

Project strategy are as follows:-

1. Collection of baseline and monitoring data and knowledge

2. Number of team and specific tasks

3. Size of cage and mesh

4. Off season monitoring

5. Site selection to transfer adult clam

Lessons learned are listed as followings:-

1.Site selection: Good lesson learned is through the importance of the approval of the local community for conservation activities. They are eyes and hear for J-Biotech's team to report any unusual activities in the conservation area. Some of the villagers voluntary dive to check and collect any clams that been toppled during monsoon. 

2. Situations that might happened to clam during to monsoon season: Assumption of strong current need to put under consideration. Upon the third design implementation, we found out that previous design (2nd), 2 cages were toppled and 1 cage shifted in 5 m from original area. Some modifications have been done in strenghtening the achor of the cages, and strong ropes were tight to all four edges of the clam cages.This is to prevent from the cages from lost or shifted or toppled down to deeper area. 

Educating communities on the hazards of unsustainable fishing practices and climate change

By working with the people’s organizations and fish wardens, the communities were sensitized on the negative effects of illegal fishing, unregulated mangrove cutting and as well as the hazards brought about by climate change.  SIKAT , a non-government organization and a member of the Locally Managed Marine Area (LMMA) Network, conducts workshops and provides support to the community organizations . They develop and distribute Information, Education, Communication (IEC) materials and distribute them to the communities to transfer knowledge and promote environment protection and conservation.   Surigao State College of Technology also mobilizes their students and faculties to do climate change related researches and to develop climate-resilient technologies for fishers and farmers, aside from conducting capacity building and public awareness raising activities on climate change. 

 

  • Presence of SIKAT, a non government organization with significant experience in implementing Community-based Coastal Resource Management and Community-based Disaster Risk Reduction and Management programs
  • Presence of a state college in Del Carmen

•It is effective to use community perceived climate change impacts in the information campaign materials , as well as documented anecdotal evidences.

Organizing and building the capacity of people’s organization

The local government unit (LGU) in Siargao Island recognized the importance of involving the communities in the implementation of adaptation strategies to ensure sustainability, and for the communities to own the responsibility in the care of their natural resources. The mayor of Del Carmen organized  fish wardens from among the local fisherfolk, trained and deputized them to enforce the fisheries laws and ordinances.  He also organized people’s organization at the village level and trained and deputized them to manage the marine protected areas, and to carry out alternative livelihood activities. Empowering these groups , through trainings other government agencies and from Sentro Para sa Ikauunland ng Katutubong Agham at Teknolohiya (SIKAT), a non-government organization implementing community-based coastal resource management and disaster risk reduction programs meant that they will be able to effectively carry out their tasks and responsibilities with minimal supervision from the LGU, and ensure the success in the implementation of adaptation strategies.  

 

  • The mayor believes in building the capacity of the community and its members and spearheaded the creation of people’s organization in all the villages in the municipality of Del Carmen.
  • The willingness of the community members to volunteer and be an active member of the people’s organization
  • Presence of NGO partner , with decades of experience in implementing community-based coastal resource management programs, in the municipality
  • Availability of the municipal fisheries ordinance

Communities play crucial role in enhancing coastal resiliency and therefore organizations from various sectors should contribute to improving the capacities of people's organizations and other resource managers.

Strict implementation of fisheries law and ordinances

The municipality of Del Carmen showed that it is serious in the implementation of fisheries law and ordinances when it organized the fish wardens and the People's Organizations (POs) in all its villages.  The local government and the Center for the Development of Indigenous Science and Technology or locally known as SIKAT, a non-government organization and a member of the Locally Managed Marine Area (LMMA) Network,  provide the fish wardens support in form of training, honorarium and provision of supplies.  The fish wardens , in partnership with law enforcers, are instrumental in the apprehension of illegal fishers and illegal mangrove cutters and in significantly lowering down the number fishermen practicing said illegal activities.  The people’s organizations were also trained and deputized by the LGU and were instrumental in the protection of designated protected areas. Sugba Lagoon likewise became a “no-fishing” zone. These efforts helped in slowly restoring the marine resources of Sugba Lagoon, and of Del Carmen.

  • The political will of the local government unit.
  • The campaigns done by both the local government and SIKAT against illegal fishing and illegal mangrove cutting which has been underway for years helped the communities correlate environment conservation and food security.  This knowledge motivated them to cooperate and participate in the people’s organizations for the establishment of the  lagoon eco tourism project.
  • Support in the campaign against illegal fishers and illegal mangrove cutter from the NGOs and people’s organizations.
  • Community members should be consulted and highly involved in the drafting of fishery policies
  • Approved municipal ordinance should be clearly communicated to stakeholders using different communication mediums.
Continuous communication and education

Through community consultations, the LGU  and non-government organizations regularly update the communities on policies and reminds them of the possible impact if the lagoon is degraded.  Dialogue on issues and discussions on solutions happen during these community consultations.  Information,  Education and Communication materials in brochure form are handed out and posters are placed in strategic locations. 

  • Participatory approach through community consultation facilitates the participation of the communities
  • The PO members have been empowered to do consultations with the other community members.
  • Community commitment on resource management and conservation depends on their level of understanding of the actual situation of their environment, ability to recognize the social and economic impacts of degraded resources, and acknowledging that they have the capacity to make their environment better.
Organized community groups and participatory approaches

The active participation of organized community groups like DECATPOA , a People's Organization (PO) from Caub village where the lagoon is, and BACAMA, a PO composed of fisherfolk is crucial in this community-based venture.  Both POs were registered with the Security and Exchange Commission, were trained and deputized by the LGU to do environmental management, particularly management of marine protected areas. SIKAT, a non-government organization with significant years of experience in community-based coastal resource management trained them on basic ecology and provided them training and support on Marine Protected Area Management. Both POs have clearly defined organizational set-up, system of rules, defined roles and clear objective on sustaining resource management.  

  • That the mayor of Del Carmen is a firm believer of capacitating the communities, has enabled the success of this building block.  He encouraged the creation of and strengthening of people’s organizations in every village.  
  • The members of the POs were willing to be volunteers. Their commitment is invaluable as they invested time and effort even if they were not sure they will earn from the venture. They believed not only in the economic benefits of tourism, but also in the importance of conserving and protecting their environment.

Having a leader who believes in empowering communities makes it easier for the community members to participate in and commit to  community-based ventures.  The spirit of volunteerism should be alive in the community for them to participate even if the economic benefits are not yet realized. 

Undergoing training  on basic ecology and marine protected area management, and being provided wth technical support by SIKAT, helped them gain better appreciation of the different strategies, as well as issues on marine protected area management.