Enhanced institutional and individual capacity for SAMP management

The institutional and individual capacity for the management of the MPAs in the SAMP were improved: a) developed or strengthen training programs for MPA management (e.g., regulatory framework, management plans, financial
sustainability, and monitoring and conservation); b) developed of planning and resource use agreements; c) supported the consolidation of the MPA management plans; d) monitoring and use of GIS tools to aid MPA management decision-making was developed; and e) assessment of the MPA management effectiveness using the METT tool was runned. Additionally, the project contributed to enhance the institutional
capacity of INVEMAR and to improved MPA management by providing funds to update monitoring/research and GIS laboratories in new headquarters in Santa Marta. The main outputs: A monitoring system for the SMPA articulated with SINAP’; Agreements for planning and resource use developed for six (6) pilot MPAs specifying roles, financial obligations, and conflict-resolution mechanisms; Selected staff from MPAs and decision-makers trained in MPA management, financial planning, and monitoring and evaluation; Existing ecology programs in higher educational institutions include MPA; Decision Support System based-GIS tools. 

  • Identification of needs for capacity building and development
  • The expectations of decision makers, sectors and MPA managers as well as scientific and academic personnel
  • The alliances between INVEMAR and their partners, as well as the possibility to link with Regional and Global Strategies (e.g. Ocean Teacher Global Academy - IOC-Unesco)
  • The postgradute programmes are open to new subjects into the currilum (MPAs, Ocean Biodiversity)

Good management needs good staff. Efforts conducted to enhance capabilities of officials towards gaining skills in managing marine environments are crucial for the success of the action.

 

Local comunities can be trained and can act as partners in the management of marine proteted areas.

Marine Protected Areas Sub-system supported by a sustainable financial framework

The sustainable financial management plans are oriented to meet the needs of the Subsystem through the identification of activities  run by the local communities which can raise revenues. Such activities include eco-tourism (scientific tourism, birdwatching, marine mammal watching), sport fishing, scenic diving and sustainable use of biodiversity resources. These plans are entailed towards the conservation of the ecosystem goods and services while giving economical opportunites to local communities and environmental entities. A financial framework ensuring the sustainability of the SAMP consolidated through the strengthening of current sources of financing and the inclusion of new ones. The framework includes the development of provisions and mechanisms to increase the current government and non-government contributions to the MPAs. Agreements to override MPA management cost with the direct beneficiaries of conservation was defined. To assess the potentiality of payments for avoided deforestation in mangroves as a financing option for MPAs and SAMP, a pilot project for the reduction of emissions caused by deforestation-degradation of mangroves was formulated and executed in Cispata. Now under replication and apply for "bluecarbon market". 

 

Identification of operational needs for the efficient and sustainable management of the marine protected areas.

 

 

Private/Public/Local comunities and institutions are a key factor to ensure the proper means to raise budgetary needs.

 

Transparency in the management of the resources and open information strategies to follow the administration are important to gain confidence of the different actors in the process.

SAMP established and supported by a legal, institutional, and operational framework.

The SMPA is established and supported by a legal, institutional, and operational framework. 

•Legal, institutional and operational framework:

8,6 million hectares under protection (8,9% aprox of marine areas)

11 new MPAs (initial target was 3)

2 Action Plans developed and supported: SIRAP Caribe y Pacífico: a) stakeholder analysis, articulation mechanisms, work plans, and specific actions for the MPAs to be included as part of action plans; b) reviewing the status of the processes for the SIRAPs’ establishment, at the same time taking into account the SINAP’s guidelines and facilitating the coordinated actions within the MPAs.

•Legal developments

SAMP Action Plan 2016 – 2023 design and start implementation

Formal adoption of SAMP by CONAP (National Protected Areas Council)

Operational agreements

Those results contributes to guarantee a representative sample of coastal and marine biodiversity at multiple biological organization levels; to assure the continuity of ecosystem services;  to maintain the natural elements asociated to material and inmaterial importance objects essencial to cultural values; and to guarantee the ecological processes maintaining the conectivity of marine biodiversity.

Political will and comunities openess to executing agency actions

The complexity of marine ecosystems need imaginative approaches towards conservation in areas where comunities are almost entirely dependent on natural goods and services.  Transactions between local stakeholders and public institutions through agreements aimed to assure sustainability of ecosystems while providing livelihoods for communities are necessary.

Funding for Nest Sponsorships through Hatchery Tours

We offer free hatchery tours to all of our guests who stay at Rimba. Here we explain to them why hatcheries are necessary for Pulau Sibiu and the processes involved. They hear in detail about how turtles naturally nest and the natural threats they need to avoid to ensure survival. 

 

We explain to them how we pay above market value for the eggs to encourage locals to sell them to us and how this money is funded by groups or individuals. From here it is up to the guests whether they would like to financially support the project by adopting a nest. 

 

It is never a "hard sell" but the question normally arises - "how is this funded?" We explain that in return the "adoptive parents" receive a video of their nest hatching, t-shirts and a certificate of adoption.

 

By providing a free educational service of a hatchery tour we are raising awareness about the turtle's struggles while at the same time offering tourists a way to support conservation. 

We have a constant stream of supporters, some who come just to visit the resort and some who learn through friends or social media about our conservation efforts. Because of these people, we are able to fund the project. We are entirely self sufficient but can only run successfully based on external funding. 

We learnt that it is a numbers game - the more hatchery tours you provide, the more nest sponsorships you receive. 

Social Media Drives for Materials

Through our social media pages we schedule a post a few times a year asking for donations from guests and supporters. We ask for materials which could be used in conservation club such as arts and crafts materials. We specify that items such as glitter are not required as they are not environmentally friendly. We also ask for them not to be brought specifically for us but items that are no longer needed that could use a new home. We receive paint, glue, fabrics etc. This helps us stick with our ethos of re-using. Items that would normally have gone in the rubbish bin are now re-used by the kids to create something meaningful.

Social media is a truly remarkable resource allowing us to reach thousands of people at any time of the day. We also have someone in the city of Johor willing to be a donation point or arrange collection to be delivered to our island. 

In our first social media drive we received lots of glitter which we are unable to use (micro plastics.) We therefore had a stash of glitter which had to be re-donated as it's options were either landfill or used and potentially entering the oceans as a micro plastic. Now we specify that no glitter be donated. 

 

The Tool: OASIIS - Opening Access to Sustainable Independent Income Streams

OASIIS is an online platform which collates data on the socio-economic activity within and beyond protected areas. By collating disperse, and often informal information, OASIIS builds a strong case for social entrepreneurship as a driver of sustainable development.

 

By showcasing the socio-economic impact as well as the stories behind the organisations, OASIIS aims to funnel social investment in order to accellerate and grow the positive social, environmental and economic impacts of businesses which have values in harmony with that of protected areas.

Mobile internet traffic accounts for 51.2% of the total global online traffic. OASIIS must be accessible and easy to use, the platform is being designed to be mobile first, in order for it to be inclusive and accessible.

OASIIS will also be a modular tool, in order for complementary tools to be added and partnerships to be integrated. 

It is therefore key that OASIIS is flexible to satisfy individual needs and build clear case studies and stories of its application, e.g. the first OASIIS Biennial Report 2018 outlines such case studies and data.

 

The current platform is a minimum viable produce (MVP) and we are currently developing a new iteration with enhancements based on user feedback.

Engaging with users and potential users has been a key process in development. 

We have conducted a pilot within UNESCO Biosphere Reserves and after the launch of the first OASIIS Biennial Report, we have decided to expand the approach to other protected areas and beyond.

The Approach: Social Enterprise and Biosphere Reserve Development Framework

The Social Enterprise and Biosphere Reserve (SEBR) Development Framework can be applied to any protected area and aims to provide a living document that will be flexible and adaptable in different countries and contexts, within their own norms, values and approaches. As such the Framework is designed as a route map towards the emergence of social enterprise as a means to promote sustainable economic development, in harmony with social and environmental sustainability. For this reason we have developed a Framework that looks at the importance of four key Factors - Public Participation, Social Enterprise, Social Investment and Sustainable Public Procurement.

The Framework can be used to plot the current context in a protected area, highlighting local strengths and weakness in relation to 4 key Factors. Once this mapping process has been carried out an Action Plan can be designed, relevant to the particular country and BR. It is likely to take around 3 years to establish the momentum necessary for this approach to become self-organising and so sustainable into the future. 

Social capital underpins the whole Social Enterprise and Biosphere Reserve Development Framework (SEBR-DF). Social capital shapes the quantity and quality of our social interactions and how well we can act collectively to tackle issues in our lives.

It is therefore a critical resource for any intervention aiming to deliver lasting benefits.

The four factors which are key to the success of the SEBR-DF are: Social enterprise; Social investment; Sustainable public procurement; and Public participation. 

Often protected area management staff hold core skills in conservation research and when it comes to an approach which includes sustainable economic development, there can be barriers to gaining support for its implementation within these areas.

Assist Social Capital have built strong partnerships within the UNESCO Biosphere Reserve community since initiating work in this sector in 2011. In order to accelerate this process ASC Co-leads and is Secretary of a MAB Thematic Network which is composed of experts in the field and meets quarterly to discuss progress and strategies to get social entrpreneurship on the MAB agenda.

 

ASC has also influenced the International Action Plan of the UNESCO Man and Biosphere Programme, the Lima Action Plan 2016-2025. The Lima Action Plan now includes supporting and including social entrepreneurs in the activities of UNESCO Biosphere Reserves. This has allowed ASC to have an officially recognised remit within the UNESCO MAB Programme, however progress to be accepted into such work streams has remained slow.

Collection mechanisms

The initiative has explored multiple fundraising strategies and mechanisms such as wristbands, souvenir sales, donations on the website, placement of ballot boxes in hotels, etc. To date, the tourist wristband has been the most successful.

The bracelet

In Islas Marietas a donation of $40 per tourist was agreed upon. Tourist service providers (TSPs) make a donation proportional to the number of tourists projected and in return get the corresponding bracelets and donation receipt. Tourists receive their bracelet when they sign up for the tour.

In sites such as Cabo Pulmo and Loreto this mechanism did not seem adequate and we are testing other options.

Other mechanisms

  • Limited edition sharks, manta rays and stuffed booby birds for sale online and at events. In some cases PSTs buy them in volume.
  • Module on the Paralelo 28 website for online donations.
  • Installation of urns in hotels to facilitate donations from tourists. In one of the cases it is accompanied by a communication campaign of the hotel.
  • In Cabo Pulmo, some PSTs and stores agreed to make monthly donations of between 1,000 and 2,000 pesos.

This building block is led by the PSTs, the local organization and Paralelo 28.

  • The commitment of more than 95% of the TSPs to support through a fair and equitable mechanism.
  • The custom in the use of the bracelet by the SWPs in Marietas favored a quick and generalized adoption.
  • A good communication campaign, explaining the meaning of the double bracelet and the importance of TSP contributions, helped to motivate support.

*Access to natural protected areas in Mexico requires a fee to be paid. In exchange for this payment a bracelet is given.

  • The bracelet is a very good mechanism to keep track of donations, to ensure that they are equitable and proportional to the volume of tourists that each company carries.
  • Selling souvenirs online requires a significant infrastructure and operational capacity, superior to that of the Paralleo 28 team (we suspended). Advance and volume sales have proven to be a good option in some cases, however, it is not very well accepted by the final sellers.
  • Ballot boxes are a fairly cost-effective mechanism for small campaign support expenditures.
  • In Mexico, online donations are rare. It is necessary to have the option, however, fundraising projections should be conservative.
  • Donation agreements for fixed monthly amounts are not recommended because it puts contributors in difficulties during low seasonal flow, besides the donation is not associated to the income generating capacity of the PST house.
  • Recognition of companies can be very important in cases where the proportion of participants is low.
Multi-sectoral partnerships, coordination and accountability mechanisms

Agreements are established between the tourism sector (service providers, hotels, sectoral groups, tourism promotion offices, etc.), civil society organizations (CSOs) and government to design and implement a collection mechanism.

Agreements are established indicating the collection and accountability mechanisms, as well as the roles of the partners.

Each year an annual operating program (POA) is developed with its corresponding budget, which specifies the items and amounts to which the investment will be allocated. The AOP is developed by the National Commission of Natural Protected Areas (CONANP) and Pronatura Noroeste (the local CSO), and presented to the board of Bahía Unida (the TSP association) for approval.

Technical and financial reports are presented every two months to the Bahía Unida board.

This building block is led by CONANP and the local CSO.

  1. Government leadership to: a) stop unsustainable tourism activities, b) promote alliances and mechanisms, and c) organize tourism activities.
  2. Integration of PST into a civil association.
  3. Existence of a credible third party implementer to manage and provide technical support.
  4. Constant communication and growing trust between individuals and later between institutions.
  5. Equity in contributions (proportional to the number of tourists).
  6. Transparency in the use of resources and accountability in the field and through high quality reports.
  1. It is necessary that there is a need for organization and action in the sector (e.g. closure of Playa del Amor). The leadership of the authority can be decisive to generate/motivate it.
  2. It is important to generate a quick and visible impact for all contributors as this generates trust and credibility (e.g. presence of vigilantes).
  3. The definition of the main purposes of the fund is fundamental. It is possible to expand them, in agreement with the contributors, if there are surpluses.
  4. Experts should design the operational programs (government + CSOs); however, contributors should have a say in their use.
  5. It is desirable to have incentives related to the needs of the contributors (e.g. marketing, preference in access to permits, etc.).
  6. Replication is possible, inside or outside natural protected areas, as long as there is a common object of interest (e.g., visiting the same site or harvesting the same species, etc.).
Guiding Urbanization by Proactive Land Readjustments

The city established a large-scale land readjustment program under the reconstruction plan. The city designated almost all replotting area by the end of 1949. The readjustment contributed re-definition of the border of land plots that became blur in the war-devastated areas and supported quick reconstruction of the city. As the result of readjustment, the ratio of the city’s public assets were significantly increased: road areas by 2.12 times (2.36 times in the urban center); public parks by 3.07 times; total areas for cemeteries by 1.30 times; and station squares by 5.25 times. The readjustment project continued until 1998 and during the rapid industrialization around 1960, land adjustment became an effective way to prevent uncontrolled sprawl into the suburbs. The city extended its urban boundaries by merging the surrounding towns and villages and conducted replotting to accommodate the increasing population.

  • Localized rules for implementing the land readjustment scheme, widely used for post-war regeneration activities
  • Growth boundaries which separated the city into Urbanization Promotion Areas (UPA) and Urbanization Control Areas (UCA)

An ideal and future-looking vision for the city was drawn up in the reconstruction plan and this helps to readjust land use and create a certain amount of public spaces for future economic development and environmental sustainability. However, at the same time, it could be a risk for cities to arbitrarily extend the urban boundary during the restoration period as land readjustments become time-consuming and costly. Thus, to guide rapid urbanization properly, it is essential to proactively regulate new property developments especially in the expanding suburban areas and expedite consensus-building among a range of stakeholders with strong economic incentives and/or social interactions.